The Principle of the Separation of Powers

The Principle of the Separation of Powers
Author: Zoltán Balázs
Publisher: Lexington Books
Total Pages: 203
Release: 2016-12-13
Genre: Political Science
ISBN: 1498523358

Download The Principle of the Separation of Powers Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

The separation of powers is one of the most cherished principles of constitutional government in the Western tradition. Despite its prestigious status, however, it has always been controversial. It has been attacked for being inadequate to account for institutional realities; for being inapplicable to parliamentary systems; for lacking a convincing normative grounding and even for being harmful, inasmuch as it hampers both the immediate enforcement of popular will and efficient political leadership. Current political crises all over the world, especially the rise of populist democracies and authoritarian regimes, however, make the principle worth a closer, more positive examination. This book takes stock of the criticisms of the principle of separation of powers and attempts to offer a new normative account of it. It argues that the separation of powers cannot be restricted to governmental institutions, agencies and decision-making procedures. Rather, it must be derived from the very basics of government, from the very notions of political order and articulated government and from the distinct though related concepts of social and governmental power and of authority. Once these distinctions are made, institutional separations are easier to be established. Contrary to the classical and most contemporary conceptions of the principle, the present account argues for a relational and negative conception of the separation of powers. The legislative branch in conceived of as the one where political authority, political power and social power are all equally represented. The executive branch is best understood as excluding social power whereas the judicial branch is marked for its opposition to the influence of political power. This conception avoids the pitfalls of essentialism and functionalism and makes the principle applicable in a much wider international context.

The Rule of Law and the Separation of Powers

The Rule of Law and the Separation of Powers
Author: Richard Bellamy
Publisher: Routledge
Total Pages: 1096
Release: 2017-07-05
Genre: History
ISBN: 1351540696

Download The Rule of Law and the Separation of Powers Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

The rule of law is frequently invoked in political debate, yet rarely defined with any precision. Some employ it as a synonym for democracy, others for the subordination of the legislature to a written constitution and its judicial guardians. It has been seen as obedience to the duly-recognised government, a form of governing through formal and general rule-like laws and the rule of principle. Given this diversity of view, it is perhaps unsurprising that certain scholars have regarded the concept as no more than a self-congratulatory rhetorical device. This collection of eighteen key essays from jurists, political theorists and public law political scientists, aims to explore the role law plays in the political system. The introduction evaluates their arguments. The first eleven essays identify the standard features associated with the rule of law. These are held to derive less from any characteristics of law per se than from a style of legislating and judging that gives equal consideration to all citizens. The next seven essays then explore how different ways of separating and dispersing power contribute to this democratic style of rule by forcing politicians and judges alike to treat people as equals and regard none as above the law.

The Spirit of Laws

The Spirit of Laws
Author: Charles de Secondat baron de Montesquieu
Publisher:
Total Pages: 492
Release: 1886
Genre: Jurisprudence
ISBN:

Download The Spirit of Laws Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

The Evolution of the Separation of Powers

The Evolution of the Separation of Powers
Author: David Bilchitz
Publisher: Edward Elgar Publishing
Total Pages: 277
Release:
Genre: Constitutional law
ISBN: 1785369776

Download The Evolution of the Separation of Powers Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

To what extent should the doctrine of the separation of powers evolve in light of recent shifts in constitutional design and practice? Constitutions now often include newer forms of rights – such as socioeconomic and environmental rights – and are written with an explicitly transformative purpose. They also often reflect include new independent bodies such as human rights commissions and electoral tribunals whose position and function within the traditional structure is novel. The practice of the separation of powers has also changed, as the executive has tended to gain power and deliberative bodies like legislatures have often been thrown into a state of crisis. The chapters in this edited volume grapple with these shifts and the ways in which the doctrine of the separation of powers might respond to them. It also asks whether the shifts that are taking place are mostly a product of the constitutional systems of the global south, or instead reflect changes that run across most liberal democratic constitutional systems around the world.

The Principles of Constitutionalism

The Principles of Constitutionalism
Author: N. W. Barber
Publisher: Oxford University Press
Total Pages: 417
Release: 2018-07-25
Genre: Law
ISBN: 0192535684

Download The Principles of Constitutionalism Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

In this follow-up volume to the critically acclaimed The Constitutional State, N. W. Barber explores how the principles of constitutionalism structure and influence successful states. Constitutionalism is not exclusively a mechanism to limit state powers. An attractive and satisfying account of constitutionalism, and, by derivation, of the state, can only be reached if the principles of constitutionalism are seen as interlocking parts of a broader doctrine. This holistic study of the relationship between the constitutional state and its central principles - sovereignty; the separation of powers; the rule of law; subsidiarity; democracy; and civil society - casts light on long-standing debates over the meaning and implications of constitutionalism. The book provides a concise introduction to constitutionalism and a detailed account of the nature and implications of each of the principles in question. It concludes with an examination of the importance of constitutional principles to the work of judges, legislators, and others involved in the operation and creation of the constitution. The book is essential reading for those seeking a definitive account of constitutionalism and its benefits.

The Separation of Governmental Powers in History, in Theory, and in the Constitutions

The Separation of Governmental Powers in History, in Theory, and in the Constitutions
Author: William Bondy
Publisher: The Lawbook Exchange, Ltd.
Total Pages: 186
Release: 1998
Genre: Separation of powers
ISBN: 188636365X

Download The Separation of Governmental Powers in History, in Theory, and in the Constitutions Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Bondy, William. Separation of Governmental Powers in History, in Theory, and in the Constitutions. New York: Columbia College, 1896. Reprinted 1999 by The Lawbook Exchange, Ltd. vi,[7]-185, [1] pp. LCCN 98-44994. ISBN 1-886363-65-X. Cloth. $65. * Examines theories relating to the powers of the court and the legislature and the separation and balance of the two. Originally published as v.5, no. 2 in Columbia's series, Studies in history, economics and public law.

Understanding Democracy

Understanding Democracy
Author: John J. Patrick
Publisher: Oxford University Press
Total Pages: 113
Release: 2006-05-25
Genre: Juvenile Nonfiction
ISBN: 0195311973

Download Understanding Democracy Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

This handy pocket guide explains the core concepts of democracy in a clear A-Z format. Though these core concepts may be practiced differently in various countries, every genuine democracy is based on them in one way or another. Ideal for civics and government classrooms, Understanding Democracy is a concise, scholarly starting point for research papers and writing assignments.

The Principles Of The Separation Of Powers And Checks And Balances As Reflected In The United States Constitution

The Principles Of The Separation Of Powers And Checks And Balances As Reflected In The United States Constitution
Author: Niklas Manhart
Publisher: GRIN Verlag
Total Pages: 14
Release: 2012-02-13
Genre: Political Science
ISBN: 3656127751

Download The Principles Of The Separation Of Powers And Checks And Balances As Reflected In The United States Constitution Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Seminar paper from the year 2008 in the subject Politics - Region: USA, grade: 1,0, University College Cork (Department of Government), course: GV2001 Politics of the United States of America, language: English, abstract: The political system of the United States is characterised by separation of powers with an elaborate system of checks and balances among the three constitutional branches: Congress the presidency and the court. In this essay I trace back this system back to the historical intention of its framers, assess the current distribution of powers and discuss problematic developments.

The Three Branches

The Three Branches
Author: Christoph Möllers
Publisher: Oxford University Press
Total Pages: 275
Release: 2013-03-14
Genre: Law
ISBN: 0199602115

Download The Three Branches Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

The idea of the separation of powers is still popular in much political and constitutional discourse, though its meaning for the modern state remains unclear and contested. This book develops a new, comprehensive, and systematic account of the principle. It then applies this new concept to legal problems of different national constitutional orders, the law of the European Union, and international institutional law. It connects an argument from normative political theory with phenomena taken from comparative constitutional law. The book argues that the conflict between individual liberty and democratic self-determination that is characteristic of modern constitutionalism is proceduralized through the establishment of different governmental branches. A close analysis of the relation between individual and collective autonomy on the one hand and the ways lawmaking through public institutions can be established on the other hand helps us identify criteria for determining how legislative, administrative, and judicial lawmaking can be distinguished and should be organized. These criteria define a common ground in the confusing variety of western constitutional traditions and their diverse use of the notion of separated powers. They also enable us to establish a normative framework that throws a fresh perspective on problems of constitutional law in different constitutional systems: constitutional judicial review of legislation, limits of legislative delegation, parliamentary control of the executive, and standing. Linking arguments from comparative constitutional law and international law, the book then uses this framework to offer a new perspective on the debate on constitutionalism beyond the state. The concept permits certain institutional insights of the constitutional experiences within states to be applied at the international level without falling into any form of methodological nationalism.

The Separation of Powers and Legislative Interference in Judicial Process

The Separation of Powers and Legislative Interference in Judicial Process
Author: Peter Gerangelos
Publisher: Hart Publishing
Total Pages: 366
Release: 2009-04-10
Genre: Law
ISBN:

Download The Separation of Powers and Legislative Interference in Judicial Process Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

This book examines the constitutional principles governing the relationship between legislatures and courts at that critical crossroads of their power where legislatures may seek to intervene in the judicial process, or to interfere with judicial functions, to secure outcomes consistent with their policy objectives or interests. Cases of high political moment are usually involved, where the temptation, indeed political imperative, for legislatures to intervene can be overwhelming. Although the methods of intervention are various, ranging from the direct and egregious to the subtle and imperceptible, unbridled legislative power in this regard has been a continuing concern in all common law jurisdictions. Prominent examples include direct legislative interference in pending cases, usurpation of judicial power by legislatures, limitations on the jurisdiction of courts, strategic amendments to law applicable to cases pending appeal, and attempts directly to overturn court decisions in particular cases. Because the doctrine of the separation of powers, as an entrenched constitutional rule, is a major source of principle, the book will examine in detail the jurisprudence of the United States and Australia in particular. These jurisdictions have identical constitutional provisions entrenching that doctrine as well as the most developed jurisprudence on this point. The legal position in the United Kingdom, which does not have an entrenched separation of powers doctrine, will be examined as a counterpoint. Other relevant jurisdictions (such as Canada, Ireland and India) are also examined in the context of particular principles, particularly when their respective jurisprudence is rather more developed on discrete points. The book examines how the relevant constitutional principles strive to maintain the primacy of the law-making role of the legislature in a representative democracy and yet afford the decisional independence of the judiciary that degree of protection essential to protect it from the legislature's 'impetuous vortex', to borrow the words of James Madison from The Federalist (No 48).