Constitutional Dialogue

Constitutional Dialogue
Author: Geoffrey Sigalet
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Total Pages: 487
Release: 2019-05-02
Genre: Law
ISBN: 1108417582

Download Constitutional Dialogue Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Identifies how and why 'dialogue' can describe and evaluate institutional interactions over constitutional questions concerning democracy and rights.

The Notwithstanding Clause

The Notwithstanding Clause
Author: Jeffrey Lawrence
Publisher:
Total Pages: 16
Release: 1989
Genre: Canada
ISBN: 9780660132990

Download The Notwithstanding Clause Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Judicial Power and Canadian Democracy

Judicial Power and Canadian Democracy
Author: Paul Howe
Publisher: McGill-Queen's Press - MQUP
Total Pages: 352
Release: 2001-03-29
Genre: Political Science
ISBN: 0773568891

Download Judicial Power and Canadian Democracy Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

The controversy raises challenging questions about the role of a powerful judiciary in a democracy. In Judicial Power and Canadian Democracy, a series of essays commissioned by the Institute for Research on Public Policy, some of Canada's foremost commentators - academics, politicians, and Supreme Court judges themselves - take up the debate. Some tangle over the pivotal question: should judges have the decisive say on issues involving entrenched rights that have profound implication for the policy preferences of elected bodies? Others examine related issues, including Supreme Court appointment procedures, interest group litigation, the historical roots of the notwithstanding clause, and the state of public opinion on Canada's courts. Those interested in the power of the judicial branch will find much in this collection to stimulate fresh thinking on issues that are likely to remain on the public agenda for years to come. Contributors include Joseph F. Fletcher (Toronto), Janet Hiebert (Queen's), Gregory Hein (Toronto), Peter W. Hogg (York), Paul Howe, Rainer Knopff (Calgary), Sébastien Lebel-Grenier (Sherbrooke), Howard Leeson (Regina), Kate Malleson (London School of Economics), E. Preston Manning (Reform Party of Canada), Hon. Beverley McLachlin (Supreme Court of Canada), F.L. Morton (Calgary), Pierre Patenaude (Sherbrooke), Peter Russell, Allison A. Thornton (Blake, Cassels and Graydon), Frederick Vaughan (emeritus, Guelph), Lorraine Eisenstat Weinrib (Toronto), Hon. Bertha Wilson (emeritus, Supreme Court of Canada), and Jacob Ziegel (Toronto).

The Notwithstanding Clause of the Charter

The Notwithstanding Clause of the Charter
Author: David Johansen
Publisher:
Total Pages: 14
Release: 2012
Genre: Civil rights
ISBN:

Download The Notwithstanding Clause of the Charter Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

The constitutional notwithstanding clause set out in section 33 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms (hereinafter referred to as the Charter of Rights or the Charter) has been controversial since its emergence from a November 1981 Federal-Provincial Conference of First Ministers. The controversy became more pronounced at the time of the 15 December 1988 Supreme Court of Canada decisions in the Ford and Devine cases dealing with the signage provisions of Quebec's Bill 101 (Charter of the French Language) and the subsequent adoption by the Quebec National Assembly of Bill 178 (An Act to Amend the Charter of the French Language). This legislation contained a section 33 override clause (in this case affecting Charter of Rights guarantees of freedom of expression (section 2(b)) and equality rights (section 15)). After setting out the content of the section 33 notwithstanding clause, this paper will trace its development in 1981 and describe the potential use then ascribed to it by its drafters, parliamentarians and others. The paper will then go on to point out actual instances when the notwithstanding clause has been invoked. Finally, it will present a number of arguments for and against the use of the clause.

The Notwithstanding Clause

The Notwithstanding Clause
Author: Ontario. Legislative Research Service
Publisher:
Total Pages: 31
Release: 1992
Genre:
ISBN:

Download The Notwithstanding Clause Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

The Notwithstanding Clause and the Canadian Charter

The Notwithstanding Clause and the Canadian Charter
Author: Peter L. Biro
Publisher: McGill-Queen's Press - MQUP
Total Pages: 277
Release: 2024-04-02
Genre: Political Science
ISBN: 0228020220

Download The Notwithstanding Clause and the Canadian Charter Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Section 33 – what is commonly referred to as the notwithstanding clause (NWC) – was written into the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms to allow Parliament and the provinces to provisionally override certain Charter rights. The Notwithstanding Clause and the Canadian Charter examines the NWC from all angles and perspectives, considering who should have the last word on matters of rights and justice – the legislatures or the unelected judiciary – and what balance liberal democracy requires. In the case of Quebec, the use of the clause has been justified as necessary to preserve the province’s culture and promote its identity as a nation. Yet Quebec’s pre-emptive and sweeping invocation of the clause also challenges the scope of judicial review and citizens’ recourse to it, and it tests the assumption that a dialogue between the judiciary and the legislature is always preferable in instances in which the legislative branch decides to suspend the operation of certain Charter rights and freedoms. By virtue of its contested purposes, interpretations, operation, and applications, the NWC represents and, to an extent, defines both the character and the very real vulnerabilities of liberal constitutionalism in Canada. The significance, effects, and legitimacy of the NWC have been vigorously debated within scholarship and among politicians and activists since the patriation of the Canadian Constitution in 1982. In The Notwithstanding Clause and the Canadian Charter leading scholars, jurists, and policy experts elucidate and prescribe reforms to the application of this consequential clause about which so much is written, and around which there is relatively little consensus.

Quebec and Section 33

Quebec and Section 33
Author: Michael B. Davie
Publisher: Manor House Pub Incorporated
Total Pages: 144
Release: 2000-01
Genre: Political Science
ISBN: 9780968580325

Download Quebec and Section 33 Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Quebec's provincial government alarmed many when it enacted its odious sign law restricting the use of English. Although this blatant human rights violation was struck down by the Supreme courts of Quebec and Canada, the provincial government enacted its sign law anyway. How? Quebec invoked the infamous Notwithstanding Clause to over-rule the highest courts in the land! Join the author as he explores Quebecs controversial use of Section 33 -- and the danger the Notwithstanding clause poses to all Canadians.

Reconceptualizing the Notwithstanding Clause

Reconceptualizing the Notwithstanding Clause
Author: Breandan Flynn
Publisher:
Total Pages: 0
Release: 2022
Genre:
ISBN:

Download Reconceptualizing the Notwithstanding Clause Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Since its entrenchment in the Canadian Constitution in 1982, The Charter of Rights and Freedoms has garnered both scrutiny and praise from supporters and detractors alike. The section of the Charter which has been, and continues to be, the most misunderstood and most highly criticized is section 33, known colloquially as the "the notwithstanding clause". S.33 is viewed by its critics as being both undemocratic and rights effacing. It is misunderstood by many of its critics as being a legislative override of judicial review, even though the word override does not appear, nor has it ever appeared, in the language of the notwithstanding clause. Rather than being considered an override, S.33, should be considered as a check and balance on judicial power, and what s.33 offers is something much more interesting and worthwhile than a simple override of judicial review. This thesis argues that s.33, rather than simply providing a legislative body with the ability to override judicial decisions with which they do not agree, provides the judicial and legislative branches of government with an avenue to further a constructive dialogue. Rather than being a check and balance which cuts the power of the judiciary off at the knees, this check and balance infuses the relationship between the judicial and legislative branches with an air of moderation. S.33 can formalize the view that the branches of government do not work independently from one another, but rather that they work interdependently with one another. In this way s.33 acts as a mechanism that can bridge the gap between Canada's history as a federation which adheres to the principle of parliamentary supremacy and Canada's current position as a federation which adheres to the principle of constitutional supremacy.

Notwithstanding

Notwithstanding
Author: Louis de Bernieres
Publisher: Vintage
Total Pages: 253
Release: 2016-10-18
Genre: Fiction
ISBN: 1101969881

Download Notwithstanding Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

As the world around it marches forward, the bucolic English village of Notwithstanding remains unchanged. It is, as it always has been, a place of pubs and cricket pitches, where local eccentrics—a retired colonel who has eschewed clothes, a spiritualist living with the ghost of her husband, and a dog named Archibald Scott-Moncrieff—almost fit in. In this delightfully evocative collection of stories, in which a young couple falls in and out of love by letter alone, an eleven-year-old boy battles a monstrous fish, and a man of the cloth has a premonition of death, Louis de Bernières conjures up a rural idyll long since forgotten. Funny, bittersweet, and deeply felt, Notwithstanding is the bestselling author of Corelli’s Mandolin at his most enchanting.

The Notwithstanding Clause of the Charter

The Notwithstanding Clause of the Charter
Author: Laurence Brosseau
Publisher:
Total Pages: 0
Release: 2018
Genre: Constitutional history
ISBN:

Download The Notwithstanding Clause of the Charter Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

"The constitutional notwithstanding clause set out in section 33 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms (hereinafter referred to as the Charter of Rights or the Charter) has been controversial since its emergence from a November 1981 Federal-Provincial Conference of First Ministers. After setting out the content of the section 33 notwithstanding clause, this Background Paper will trace its development in 1981 and describe the potential use then ascribed to it by its drafters, parliamentarians and others. The paper will then go on to point out actual instances when the notwithstanding clause has been invoked. Finally, it will present a number of arguments for and against the use of the clause"--Introduction, page 1