The Application of Chemometrics to the Detection and Classification of Ignitable Liquids in Fire Debris Using the Total Ion Spectrum

The Application of Chemometrics to the Detection and Classification of Ignitable Liquids in Fire Debris Using the Total Ion Spectrum
Author: Jennifer N. Lewis
Publisher:
Total Pages: 274
Release: 2011
Genre: Chemometrics
ISBN:

Download The Application of Chemometrics to the Detection and Classification of Ignitable Liquids in Fire Debris Using the Total Ion Spectrum Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Current methods in ignitable liquid identification and classification from fire debris rely on pattern recognition of ignitable liquids in total ion chromatograms, extracted ion profiles, and target compound comparisons, as described in American Standards for Testing and Materials E1618-10. The total ion spectra method takes advantage of the reproducibility among sample spectra from the same American Society for Testing and Materials class. It is a method that is independent of the chromatographic conditions that affect retention times of target compounds, thus aiding in the use of computer-based library searching techniques. The total ion spectrum was obtained by summing the ion intensities across all retention times. The total ion spectrum from multiple fire debris samples were combined for target factor analysis. Principal components analysis allowed the dimensions of the data matrix to be reduced prior to target factor analysis, and the number of principal components retained was based on the determination of rank by median absolute deviation. The latent variables were rotated to find new vectors (resultant vectors) that were the best possible match to spectra in a reference library of over 450 ignitable liquid spectra (test factors). The Pearson correlation between target factors and resultant vectors were used to rank the ignitable liquids in the library. Ignitable liquids with the highest correlation represented possible contributions to the sample. Posterior probabilities for the ASTM ignitable liquid classes were calculated based on the probability distribution function of the correlation values. The ASTM ignitable liquid class present in the sample set was identified based on the class with the highest posterior probability value. Tests included computer simulations of artificially generated total ion spectra from a combination of ignitable liquid and substrate spectra, as well as large scale burns in 20'x8'x8' containers complete with furnishings and flooring. Computer simulations were performed for each ASTM ignitable liquid class across a range of parameters. Of the total number of total ion spectra in a data set, the percentage of samples containing an ignitable liquid was varied, as well as the percent of ignitable liquid contribution in a given total ion spectrum. Target factor analysis was them performed on the computer-generated sample set. The correlation values from target factor analysis were used to calculate posterior probabilities for each ASTM ignitable liquid class. Large scale burns were designed to test the detection capabilities of the chemometric approach to ignitable liquid detection under conditions similar to those of a structure fire. Burn conditions were controlled by adjusting the type and volume of ignitable liquid used, the fuel load, ventilation, and the elapsed time of the burn. Samples collected from the large scale burns were analyzed using passive headspace adsorption with activated charcoal strips and carbon disulfide desorption of volatiles for analysis using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry.

Chemometric Applications to a Complex Classification Problem

Chemometric Applications to a Complex Classification Problem
Author: Erin Elizabeth Waddell
Publisher:
Total Pages: 298
Release: 2013
Genre:
ISBN:

Download Chemometric Applications to a Complex Classification Problem Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Fire debris analysis currently relies on visual pattern recognition of the total ion chromatograms, extracted ion profiles, and target compound chromatograms to identify the presence of an ignitable liquid. This procedure is described in the ASTM International E1618-10 standard method. For large data sets, this methodology can be time consuming and is a subjective method, the accuracy of which is dependent upon the skill and experience of the analyst. This research aimed to develop an automated classification method for large data sets and investigated the use of the total ion spectrum (TIS). The TIS is calculated by taking an average mass spectrum across the entire chromatographic range and has been shown to contain sufficient information content for the identification of ignitable liquids. The TIS of ignitable liquids and substrates were compiled into model data sets. Substrates are defined as common building materials and household furnishings that are typically found at the scene of a fire and are, therefore, present in fire debris samples. Fire debris samples were also used which were obtained from laboratory-scale and large-scale burns. An automated classification method was developed using computational software, that was written in-house. Within this method, a multi-step classification scheme was used to detect ignitable liquid residues in fire debris samples and assign these to the classes defined in ASTM E1618-10. Classifications were made using linear discriminant analysis, quadratic discriminant analysis (QDA), and soft independent modeling of class analogy (SIMCA). The model data sets were tested by cross-validation and used to classify fire debris samples. Correct classification rates were calculated for each data set. Classifier performance metrics were also calculated for the first step of the classification scheme which included false positive rates, true positive rates, and the precision of the method. The first step, which determines a sample to be positive or negative for ignitable liquid residue, is arguably the most important in the forensic application. Overall, the highest correct classification rates were achieved using QDA for the first step of the scheme and SIMCA for the remaining steps. In the first step of the classification scheme, correct classification rates of 95.3% and 89.2% were obtained using QDA to classify the cross-validation test set and fire debris samples, respectively. For this step, the cross-validation test set resulted in a true positive rate of 96.2%, a false positive rate of 9.3%, and a precision of 98.2%. The fire debris data set had a true positive rate of 82.9%, a false positive rate of 1.3%, and a precision of 99.0%. Correct classifications rates of 100% were achieved for both data sets in the majority of the remaining steps which used SIMCA for classification. The lowest correct classification rate, 69.2%, was obtained for the fire debris samples in one of the final steps in the classification scheme. In this research, the first statistically valid error rates for fire debris analysis have been developed through cross-validation of large data sets. The fire debris analyst can use the automated method as a tool for detecting and classifying ignitable liquid residues in fire debris samples. The error rates reduce the subjectivity associated with the current methods and provide a level of confidence in sample classification that does not currently exist in forensic fire debris analysis.

Determining the Presence of an Ignitable Liquid Residue in Fire Debris Samples Utilizing Target Factor Analysis

Determining the Presence of an Ignitable Liquid Residue in Fire Debris Samples Utilizing Target Factor Analysis
Author: Kelly M. McHugh
Publisher:
Total Pages: 106
Release: 2010
Genre: Fire investigation
ISBN:

Download Determining the Presence of an Ignitable Liquid Residue in Fire Debris Samples Utilizing Target Factor Analysis Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Current fire debris analysis procedure involves using the chromatographic patterns of total ion chromatograms, extracted ion chromatograms, and target compound analysis to identify an ignitable liquid according to the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) E 1618 standard method. Classifying the ignitable liquid is accomplished by a visual comparison of chromatographic data obtained from any extracted ignitable liquid residue in the debris to the chromatograms of ignitable liquids in a database, i.e. by visual pattern recognition. Pattern recognition proves time consuming and introduces potential for human error. One particularly difficult aspect of fire debris analysis is recognizing an ignitable liquid residue when the intensity of its chromatographic pattern is extremely low or masked by pyrolysis products. In this research, a unique approach to fire debris analysis was applied by utilizing the samples' total ion spectrum (TIS) to identify an ignitable liquid, if present. The TIS, created by summing the intensity of each ion across all elution times in a gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) dataset retains sufficient information content for the identification of complex mixtures . Computer assisted spectral comparison was then performed on the samples' TIS by target factor analysis (TFA). This approach allowed rapid automated searching against a library of ignitable liquid summed ion spectra. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves measured how well TFA identified ignitable liquids in the database that were of the same ASTM classification as the ignitable liquid in fire debris samples, as depicted in their corresponding area under the ROC curve. This study incorporated statistical analysis to aid in classification of an ignitable liquid, therefore alleviating interpretive error inherent in visual pattern recognition. This method could allow an analyst to declare an ignitable liquid present when utilization of visual pattern recognition alone is not sufficient.

GC-MS Guide to Ignitable Liquids

GC-MS Guide to Ignitable Liquids
Author: Reta Newman
Publisher: CRC Press
Total Pages: 802
Release: 2020-08-26
Genre: Law
ISBN: 1000141233

Download GC-MS Guide to Ignitable Liquids Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

The rapidly increasing number of different ignitable liquid formulations available today poses a new challenge to fire debris analysts and other forensic chemistry specialists - that of accurately identifying and classifying ignitable liquids with unfamiliar chromatographic patterns. GC-MS Guide to Ignitable Liquids addresses that challenge with a selection of more than 100 different ignitable liquid formulations designed to supplement the laboratory's standard collection. Both total ion chromatograms and extracted ion chromatograms (mass chromatograms) are included. Written by authors who are also experienced forensic chemists, this complete reference is the only single source of information on ignitable liquids - a must for students of fire science, forensic chemists, and anyone conducting fire debris analysis.

Application of Chemometrics and Fast GC-MS Analysis for the Identification of Ignitable Liquids in Fire Debris Samples

Application of Chemometrics and Fast GC-MS Analysis for the Identification of Ignitable Liquids in Fire Debris Samples
Author: Michael E. Sigman
Publisher:
Total Pages: 44
Release: 2012
Genre: Chemometrics
ISBN:

Download Application of Chemometrics and Fast GC-MS Analysis for the Identification of Ignitable Liquids in Fire Debris Samples Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

The goal of the research conducted under this grant was to develop a chemometric method of data analysis that would facilitate the identification of GC-MS patterns associated with ignitable liquid classes, as designated under ASTM E 1618-10. The objective of the research was to develop a data analysis method that would classify ignitable liquid residue in the presence of background interferences found in fire debris. Pattern recognition and classification methods available at the onset of this research did not explicitly take into account background interference issues. A novel method was developed under this research to classify ignitable liquid residues into the ASTM classes, even in the presence of a strong background signal, without a priori knowledge of the background signature. The method makes use of target factor analysis (TFA) in combination with Bayesian decision theory. The use of Bayesian decision theory provides results in the form of posterior probabilities that a set of samples from a fire scene contain an ignitable liquid of a specific ASTM class. Error rates are not currently available for fire debris analysis, other than extrapolations from proficiency tests. The method was further refined by introducing a sensitivity parameter which made the method very conservative in its predictions, and gave a true "soft" classifier. Soft classifiers allow classification of a sample into multiple classes and afford the possibility of not assigning the sample to any of the available classes. In order to achieve the goals, this work was broken down into three tasks.

Fire Debris Analysis

Fire Debris Analysis
Author: Eric Stauffer
Publisher: Academic Press
Total Pages: 683
Release: 2007-12-10
Genre: Law
ISBN: 0080556264

Download Fire Debris Analysis Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

The study of fire debris analysis is vital to the function of all fire investigations, and, as such, Fire Debris Analysis is an essential resource for fire investigators. The present methods of analysis include the use of gas chromatography and gas chromatography-mass spectrometry, techniques which are well established and used by crime laboratories throughout the world. However, despite their universality, this is the first comprehensive resource that addresses their application to fire debris analysis. Fire Debris Analysis covers topics such as the physics and chemistry of fire and liquid fuels, the interpretation of data obtained from fire debris, and the future of the subject. Its cutting-edge material and experienced author team distinguishes this book as a quality reference that should be on the shelves of all crime laboratories. Serves as a comprehensive guide to the science of fire debris analysis Presents both basic and advanced concepts in an easily readable, logical sequence Includes a full-color insert with figures that illustrate key concepts discussed in the text

Classification of Ground-truth Fire Debris Samples Using Neural Networks

Classification of Ground-truth Fire Debris Samples Using Neural Networks
Author: Nicholas Alan Thurn
Publisher:
Total Pages: 127
Release: 2021
Genre:
ISBN:

Download Classification of Ground-truth Fire Debris Samples Using Neural Networks Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Fire debris samples are currently analyzed according to ASTM E1618-19, which is the “Standard Test Method for Ignitable Liquid Residues in Extracts from Fire Debris Samples by Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry.” This method requires that an analyst make a visual comparison to an appropriate reference sample using the total ion and the extracted ion chromatograms. The analyst then provides an opinion about whether an ignitable liquid residue is present in the sample. The method is inherently subjective due to the visual interpretation that is needed. In order to automate this process, this work uses neural networks and a subset of the ions specified in ASTM E1618-19, which represent many of the compounds present in ignitable liquids, to cluster and classify ground-truth fire debris samples. The first part of this work demonstrates that these ions provide sufficient information to allow for the clustering of the ignitable liquid classes defined in ASTM E1618-19 and substate pyrolysis extracts using self-organizing maps. Classification using self-organizing maps resulted in a 96% correct classification rate on an independent test set. The latter portion of this work demonstrates the use of the ASTM ions in conjunction with feedforward neural networks to evaluate laboratory prepared ground-truth fire debris samples. An optimal neural network model was selected from a set of candidate models that were trained on in-silico fire debris samples. Receiver operating characteristic curves were used to select an optimal decision threshold for classifying a fire debris sample as positive or negative for ignitable liquid residues using a false positive to false negative cost ratio of 10. The use of this threshold for classification resulted in a somewhat conservative model with a true positive rate of 0.59 and a false positive rate of 0.07 for a set of laboratory-generated ground-truth fire debris samples.

Forensic Analysis of Ignitable Liquids in Fire Debris by Comprehensive Two-Dimensional Gas Chromatography

Forensic Analysis of Ignitable Liquids in Fire Debris by Comprehensive Two-Dimensional Gas Chromatography
Author: GS. Frysinger
Publisher:
Total Pages: 12
Release: 2002
Genre: Accelerant
ISBN:

Download Forensic Analysis of Ignitable Liquids in Fire Debris by Comprehensive Two-Dimensional Gas Chromatography Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

The application of comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography (GC × GC) for the forensic analysis of ignitable liquids in fire debris is reported. GC × GC is a high resolution, multidimensional gas chromatographic method in which each component of a complex mixture is subjected to two independent chromatographic separations. The high resolving power of GC × GC can separate hundreds of chemical components from a complex fire debris extract. The GC × GC chromatogram is a multicolor plot of two-dimensional retention time and detector signal intensity that is well suited for rapid identification and fingerprinting of ignitable liquids. GC × GC chromatograms were used to identify and classify ignitable liquids, detect minor differences between similar ignitable liquids, track the chemical changes associated with weathering, characterize the chemical composition of fire debris pyrolysates, and detect weathered ignitable liquids against a background of fire debris pyrolysates.

The Discrimination of Ignitable Liquids and Ignitable Liquid Residues Using Chemometric Analysis

The Discrimination of Ignitable Liquids and Ignitable Liquid Residues Using Chemometric Analysis
Author: Wan Nur Syuhaila Binti Mat Desa
Publisher:
Total Pages: 0
Release: 2012
Genre:
ISBN:

Download The Discrimination of Ignitable Liquids and Ignitable Liquid Residues Using Chemometric Analysis Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Hydrocarbon fuels such as petrol and petroleum distillate products are commonly used to set deliberate fires. In fire debris analysis, characterisation and identification of these accelerants are based on subjective pattern matching to a reference collection or database. Such procedures involving manual comparison, is often hampered by the complex nature of the samples when exposed to heat, especially in the presence of interfering products and can be extremely challenging. The application of chemometrics and Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs) pattern recognition techniques are examined in this work to determine their abilities to objectively match chromatographic profiles derived from evaporated ignitable liquid samples to their un-evaporated source. The abilities of the mathematical methods to further resolve ignitable liquid patterns when in the presence of interfering pyrolysis and combustion products is also investigated. Data pre-treatment via normalisation and power transformation prior mathematical analysis is examined and discussed. Petrol and petroleum distillate products of light, medium and heavy fractions, obtained from a variety of manufacturers, were examined. Their objective classification and discrimination using the mathematical techniques under study is exposed and discussed. The link between evaporated and unevaporated samples was poorly established by conventional chemometric techniques using Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and Hierarchical Cluster Analysis (HCA). In contrast, Self Organising Feature Maps (SOFM), an ANN technique, provided excellent classification and full discrimination of light and medium petroleum distillate samples by specific brand. Classifications of petrol and diesel samples by brand were less successful. However, some meaningful associations were possible within the petrol groupings using SOFM, and all evaporated samples were correctly associated into the clusters containing their un-evaporated counterparts. In addition, SOFM provided successful and unequivocal discrimination of ignitable liquid residues recovered from fire debris according to the class of ignitable liquid in all samples tested. The findings from this work prompt further exploration on the potential use of SOFM as a mathematical strategy for the objective comparison of ignitable liquids and their residues from fire debris samples.