Ominous news from a phone call unites Bobby, Randy, Gerry and Art who are now in their early thirties. At this time of life family and careers are their main responsibilities, although Randy is still single, however he is in a relationship. They have already dealt with significant complications and have provided support to each other through the passing years. At the same time, the interaction with new people has introduced an intriguing mystery which takes them on a new journey. However, the pursuit to uncover this dark secret could have negative effects on some of their relationships. Decisions have to be made about whether or not to continue with the investigation or to leave the past as is. Since all but Randy no longer live in their home town of Wattinger, some travelling is required for their reunions which now limits their ability to get together due to the new requirements of family life. As part of their reunion they meet in Wattinger to connect with family and friends, For Bobby, it's a time to reestablish a relationship with his father that had deteriorated during his years as a teen. The crisis with the mystery had surprising revelations for numerous people who were affected by it.