The infant industry argument - valid or not?

The infant industry argument - valid or not?
Author: Wiebke Klingemann
Publisher: GRIN Verlag
Total Pages: 19
Release: 2012-07-17
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 3656235384

Download The infant industry argument - valid or not? Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Seminar paper from the year 2012 in the subject Economics - International Economic Relations, Hamburg University of Applied Sciences, course: International economics, language: English, abstract: “Even if a domestic industry will, within some years, have a cost advantage over its foreign competitors, when the industry is young its costs will invariably be higher ... [and it must therefore] be protected from lower-cost foreign competition” (Egger, 2006, p.9). The infant industry argument (IIA), initially devised by Alexander Hamilton (in 1791) and Friedrich List (in 1841) (Hoekman, 2001, p. 23), is a widely-used concept to justify the protection of young start-up companies against international competition. By invoking the IIA - which is even recognized by the WTO as a legitimate reason for restricting trade - countries apply protective regulations in favour of their domestic industries through various measures such as tariffs, import quotas and subsidies (Hill, 2009, p. 218). But just like every trade barrier, the argument is intensively discussed and contradicted in economic science. Adversaries of the concept show the danger of abuse, and question its validity in general, referring to the scientifically proven advantages of free trade. By analyzing its pros and cons and showing successful examples as well as downsides of the concept, this paper will therefore examine whether the IIA can be considered to be valid, and if so, under which circumstances it should be applied.

International Trade: Friedrich List's Theory of the infant industry argument

International Trade: Friedrich List's Theory of the infant industry argument
Author: Matthias Hilgert
Publisher: GRIN Verlag
Total Pages: 16
Release: 2005-05-03
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 3638373584

Download International Trade: Friedrich List's Theory of the infant industry argument Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Essay from the year 2005 in the subject Economics - International Economic Relations, grade: very good (UK: grade A, mark 7), University of Glasgow (Center of Development Studies), course: International Trade, language: English, abstract: The infant industry argument is one of the most famous arguments for protection against free international trade. The argument claims that protection is justified for new industries especially in less developed countries in order to establish them sufficiently. These infant industries are unable to compete with the old and well established industries located mostly in developed countries. The main reasons are differences in efficiency in production, information, knowledge and capital endowment (Suranovic, 2004). Since Friedrich List (1789-1846) had developed this argument at the beginning of the Nineteenth Century, since then infant industry protection has been immensely criticized among economists. Most economists agree to some reasonable circumstances that would justify the temporary and limited protection of an infant industry (Melitz, 1999). Nevertheless, there is a big community of opponents who claim that protection is likely to be only the second-best policy rather than the firstbest policy (Suranovic, 2004). Despite this opposition, almost all countries of the world have developed their industrial base by applying to infant industry protection (Krugman and Obstfeld, 2003 and Shafaeddin, 1998). This essay aims to examine Friedrich List’s theory of the infant industry argument in detail. First, it explores the origin of List’s theory by giving a general explanation and some background information, by identifying the pattern of protection and by examining the justification for his theory. Secondly, it critically examines List’s theory under a contemporary perspective by discussing the current issues of the infant industries argument. Finally, it asks the question, if List’s theory is still valid.

Kicking Away the Ladder

Kicking Away the Ladder
Author: Ha-Joon Chang
Publisher: Anthem Press
Total Pages: 196
Release: 2002-07-01
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 0857287613

Download Kicking Away the Ladder Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

How did the rich countries really become rich? In this provocative study, Ha-Joon Chang examines the great pressure on developing countries from the developed world to adopt certain 'good policies' and 'good institutions', seen today as necessary for economic development. His conclusions are compelling and disturbing: that developed countries are attempting to 'kick away the ladder' with which they have climbed to the top, thereby preventing developing countries from adopting policies and institutions that they themselves have used.

What Did Frederick List Actually Say?

What Did Frederick List Actually Say?
Author: Mehdi Shafaeddin
Publisher:
Total Pages: 36
Release: 2000
Genre: Industrialization
ISBN:

Download What Did Frederick List Actually Say? Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

The purpose of this study is to clarify some confusion surrounding the infant industry argument presented by Frederick List. Its main contribution is to show that List recommended selective, rather than across-the-board, protection of infant industries and that he was against neither international trade nor export expansion. In fact, he emphasizes the importance of trade and envisages free trade as an ultimate aim of all nations; he regards protection as an instrument for achieving development, massive export expansion and ultimately free trade. List's theory was a dynamic one, with dimensions of time and geography. Making a distinction between 'universal association' and national interest, he argues that infant industry protection is necessary for countries at early stages of industrialization if some countries 'outdistanced others in manufactures'. Nevertheless, protection should be temporary, targeted and not excessive. Domestic competition should in due course be introduced, preceded by planned, gradual and targeted trade liberalization. List guards, however, against premature liberalization. He is aware of the limitation of size for infant industry protection but claims that in most cases this obstacle could be overcome through collaboration with other countries. To List, trade policy is not a panacea; it is an element in his general theory of 'productive power' (development); industrial development also requires a host of other socio-economic measures. The infant industry argument is not only still valid, if properly applied, but, in fact, it is at present even more relevant owing to recent technological revolution and changes in the organization of production. But despite this increased need, the means to achieving it have been restricted by international trade rules. The study also refers to significant incidences of targeted protection of production and exports in advanced countries, while universal and across-the-board liberalization is recommended for developing countries. International trade rules need to be revised to aim at achieving a fair trading system, in which the differential situations of countries at various stages of development are taken into greater consideration. Universal free trade may be easier for developing countries to implement th an a dynamic and targeted trade policy; but 'easiness' is not a substitute for 'soundness'. It is emphasized, however, that, as List maintained, after a point in time trade should be liberalized selectively and gradually, aiming at the ultimate goal of free trade when all nations have reached the same level of development.

Infant Industry Argument

Infant Industry Argument
Author: Mamdouh Abdelkader
Publisher:
Total Pages: 17
Release: 2018
Genre:
ISBN:

Download Infant Industry Argument Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

This paper verifies the possibility of using Infant industry protection strategy to improve manufacturing competitiveness in developing countries. The main theoretical bases of this strategy are: its significant role in creating dynamic comparative advantages in manufacturing sector. This protection also gives the industry time to learn by doing and achieve its positive externalities. In addition, infant industry protection can be a virtual solution to market failure which may impedes the establishment of such industry. This study supports infant industry argument validity by showing successful experiences of some countries at various times in history. It is found that most countries used such policy to reach their industrialization. Some studies tried to refute the infant industry argument but they based their criticism mainly on the failure of some developing countries to correctly apply this policy, not on their theoretical justification. Despite current WTO restriction to use infant industry, the paper argues that the chance of adopting this strategy still exists. This can be mainly achieved by some policy space of WTO rules to adopt this policy, especially if these countries focus on technology intensive industries. In addition, developing countries can exploit the increasing number of Regional Trade Agreements (RTAs) to support their infant industries. RTAs extend the market size that may help infant industries to develop their competitiveness through achieving economies of scale, learning by doing and supporting backward and forward linkages.