Generating Evidence for Genomic Diagnostic Test Development

Generating Evidence for Genomic Diagnostic Test Development
Author: Institute of Medicine
Publisher: National Academies Press
Total Pages: 106
Release: 2011-07-27
Genre: Medical
ISBN: 0309211042

Download Generating Evidence for Genomic Diagnostic Test Development Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Ten years after the sequencing of the human genome, scientists have developed genetic tests that can predict a person's response to certain drugs, estimate the risk of developing Alzheimer's disease, and make other predictions based on known links between genes and diseases. However, genetic tests have yet to become a routine part of medical care, in part because there is not enough evidence to show they help improve patients' health. The Institute of Medicine (IOM) held a workshop to explore how researchers can gather better evidence more efficiently on the clinical utility of genetic tests. Generating Evidence for Genomic Diagnostic Test Development compares the evidence that is required for decisions regarding clearance, use, and reimbursement, to the evidence that is currently generated. The report also addresses innovative and efficient ways to generate high-quality evidence, as well as barriers to generating this evidence. Generating Evidence for Genomic Diagnostic Test Development contains information that will be of great value to regulators and policymakers, payers, health-care providers, researchers, funders, and evidence-based review groups.

Genome-Based Diagnostics

Genome-Based Diagnostics
Author: Institute of Medicine
Publisher: National Academies Press
Total Pages: 104
Release: 2012-07-27
Genre: Medical
ISBN: 0309253942

Download Genome-Based Diagnostics Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

The sequencing of the human genome and the identification of associations between specific genetic variants and diseases have led to an explosion of genomic-based diagnostic tests. These tests have the potential to direct therapeutic interventions, predict risk or onset of disease, or detect residual disease. As research progresses and an increasing number of associations are found, further tests will be developed that can aid in providing personalized treatment options for patients. However, the adoption of genomic diagnostic tests by health care providers has been limited due to a lack of evidence regarding the clinical utility of many tests. Health funders and practitioners lack the data necessary to distinguish which tests can improve practice or the clinical settings in which tests will provide the greatest value. The Roundtable on Translating Genomic-Based Research for Health held a workshop in November 2010 to determine what evidence is needed and how it is viewed by different stakeholders in order to develop genomic diagnostic tests of clinical value. Genome-Based Diagnostics summarizes the presentations and discussions that took place throughout the workshop. Two presentations, in particular, sparked extensive discussion. One presentation proposed that all genomic diagnostic tests be reviewed and approved by the Food and Drug Administration. The other observed that venture capitalists are no longer investing substantially in the development of genomic diagnostic tests because of a lack of clarity surrounding regulatory and reimbursement pathways. Both presentations suggested the need for major changes in the systems used to develop, regulate, and reimburse genomic diagnostic tests. The report also presents the perspectives of different stakeholders in the development of genomic diagnostic tests. Each stakeholder group has a different set of needs and issues of importance, yet commonalities among them are apparent, such as the need to put patients and health outcomes at the center of discussion and action.

Genome-Based Diagnostics

Genome-Based Diagnostics
Author: Roundtable on Translating Genomic-Based Research for Health
Publisher: National Academies Press
Total Pages: 0
Release: 2014-01-10
Genre: Medical
ISBN: 9780309269599

Download Genome-Based Diagnostics Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Genome-Based Diagnostics: Demonstrating Clinical Utility in Oncology is the summary of a workshop convened in May 2012 by the Roundtable on Translating Genomic-Based Research for Health and the Center for Medical Technology Policy of the Institute of Medicine to foster the identified need for further sustained dialogue between stakeholders regarding the clinical utility of molecular diagnostics. The workshop brought together a wide range of stakeholders, including patients, health care providers, policy makers, payers, diagnostic test developers, researchers, and guideline developers, to identify the challenges and opportunities in advancing the development and use of molecular diagnostic tests designed to guide the treatment and management of patients with cancer. The sequencing of the human genome has greatly accelerated the process of linking specific genetic variants with disease. These findings have yielded a rapidly increasing number of molecular diagnostic tests designed to guide disease treatment and management. Many of these tests are aimed at determining the best treatments for specific forms of cancer, making oncology a valuable testing ground for the use of molecular diagnostic tests in medicine in general. Nevertheless, many questions surround the clinical value of molecular diagnostic tests, and their acceptance by clinicians, payers, and patients has been unpredictable. A major limiting factor for the use of these tests has been the lack of clear evidence of clinical utility. Genome-Based Diagnostics assesses the evidentiary requirements for clinical utility of molecular diagnostics used to guide treatment decisions for patients with cancer; discusses methodologies related to demonstrating these evidentiary requirements that meet the needs of all stakeholders; and considers innovative, sustainable research collaborations for generating evidence of clinical utility involving multiple stakeholders.

An Evidence Framework for Genetic Testing

An Evidence Framework for Genetic Testing
Author: National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine
Publisher: National Academies Press
Total Pages: 149
Release: 2017-04-21
Genre: Medical
ISBN: 0309453291

Download An Evidence Framework for Genetic Testing Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Advances in genetics and genomics are transforming medical practice, resulting in a dramatic growth of genetic testing in the health care system. The rapid development of new technologies, however, has also brought challenges, including the need for rigorous evaluation of the validity and utility of genetic tests, questions regarding the best ways to incorporate them into medical practice, and how to weigh their cost against potential short- and long-term benefits. As the availability of genetic tests increases so do concerns about the achievement of meaningful improvements in clinical outcomes, costs of testing, and the potential for accentuating medical care inequality. Given the rapid pace in the development of genetic tests and new testing technologies, An Evidence Framework for Genetic Testing seeks to advance the development of an adequate evidence base for genetic tests to improve patient care and treatment. Additionally, this report recommends a framework for decision-making regarding the use of genetic tests in clinical care.

Health Economics of Genomic Medicine

Health Economics of Genomic Medicine
Author: Sarah Wordsworth
Publisher:
Total Pages: 250
Release: 2022-01-15
Genre:
ISBN: 9783110699555

Download Health Economics of Genomic Medicine Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Although genomic medicine is still a fairly new clinical area, the history of health economics involvement in genomics has a longer history than might be anticipated. Some of the earliest health economics input into genomics was in areas such as neonatal and newborn screening, where health economists contributed to decisions about adding new conditions into newborn screening programmes worldwide. More recently, the first human genome was only sequenced in 2003, costing between US$500 million and US$1 billion. However, by 2008 costs had fallen to a level where so called 'next-generation sequencing (NGS)' approaches started to enter clinical research. NGS approaches allow either the whole genome using methods such as whole-genome sequencing (WGS) or parts of it using whole-exome sequencing (WES) or targeted panels to be sequenced in hours with increased sensitivity compared to older less advanced genetic testing approaches. These sequencing approaches provide information that can inform diagnosis, prognosis and clinical management for a variety of disorders, such as rare diseases and some cancers. However, the current costs are still too expensive for some health care providers and the benefit of the tests is largely unknown. Indeed, a lack of evidence on the cost-effectiveness of novel genomic technologies such as WGS is considered a key translational challenge. This is partly because economic evaluations of genomic technologies often fall outside the remit of health technology assessment (HTA) agencies, such as NICE and PBAC. Where they are undertaken (in a HTA context), the methods used for the assessment sometimes differ from those recommended by HTA agencies for cost-effectiveness analysis. This is against a background of uncertainty as to whether the terms precision medicine, personalised medicine or genomic medicine best capture this space in health care. Methodological challenges Some applications of genomic sequencing generate information that may not improve quality of life (as measured using preference-based health-related quality of life [HRQoL] instruments such as the EuroQol-five dimensions questionnaire) or extend life expectancy. One example is the use of WGS and WES to guide diagnosis in autism spectrum disorder. However, genomic sequencing results may influence patient wellbeing via non-clinical routes, generating 'personal utility'. This is a particular issue for individuals with rare diseases, who often have lengthy diagnostic journeys but few (if any) treatment options available once they receive a diagnosis. This could also be an issue if individuals without known health problems (healthy cohorts) undergo genomic sequencing and find out that they have an elevated risk of a disease, but no preventive action can be taken to manage this risk. With respect to costs, the costs of undertaking genomic tests are only one component of the cost of the overall genomic testing process. The costs that are incurred beyond those associated with the production of genomic information (so probably beyond the scope of any national tariffs that might be generated) include the costs of bioinformatics analysis, interpretation of results in multidisciplinary team (MDT) meetings and genetic counselling services. Such issues have raised questions about whether or not genomics is exceptional for health economists - possibly not, but the combined issues perhaps lead to it often requiring additional attention. There is also a consideration of the importance of accounting for the 'personal' when evaluating personalized medicine and considers the extent to which extra-welfarist and welfarist approaches to economic evaluation achieve this objective. Extra-welfarist approaches are currently used by many health technology assessment agencies but may not capture all of the outcomes that are important to patients in this context. Extensions to the extra-welfarist approach that might better capture the 'personal' are outlined, including multi-criteria decision analysis and the capability approach. Evidence A recent literature review identified only 36 economic evaluations of either WGS or WES, six of which were cost-effectiveness analyses using diagnostic yield as the outcome measure. Only two publications presented cost-utility analyses using quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) as the measure of health outcomes. HTA agencies generally require data on survival and quality of life when evaluating new healthcare interventions, which, when combined, allow clinical utility to be quantified using QALYs. However, existing studies have primarily quantified the clinical utility of genomic tests in terms of changes in diagnostic yield. Methodological uncertainty among health economists is one potential explanation for the lack of evidence on the health outcomes associated with genomic sequencing. Over the past decade, health economists have repeatedly questioned whether metrics such as the QALY in genomic medicine, which focuses on clinical utility, can fully quantify the outcomes that are important to patients when they undergo genomic testing. Policy picture There are high-level discussions in several countries, including the UK, about extending the use of genomic sequencing into newborning screening, so effectively screening everyone at birth for a large range of conditions, far more than those currently being screened for and which there might not be treatments for yet. This is in addition to long term epidemiological and health economic discussions on using newborn screening for conditions such as hereditary hemochromatosis. A further area of uncertainty is the use of genomic sequencing in 'healthy populations', including direct to consumer testing (private genetic tests). In a public health care system setting, the UK Department of health is exploring the value of establishing a healthy cohort of volunteer. Furthermore, research studies are assessing the costs and effects of polygenetic risk scores in the context of primary care as an opportunistic 'health check' approach, which could incorporate risks for cardiovascular disease, diabetes, different cancers and conditions such as chrohn's disease etc. Clearly, there are health economic questions to be asked about the downstream costs and consequences of genomic tests in these newborn and 'healthy' populations. In cancer, there are discussions about how to handle the new invention of agnostic cancer drugs (which essentially target the mutation rather than the cancer, so the same drug can treat several cancers). This is an area where assessments are going through HTA agencies who are unsure about the best approaches to adopt to these assessments where drug companies are putting forward a drug for assessment that can potentially treat different cancers with very different disease profiles. These developments require careful consideration from many perspectives, including health economics. Besides highlighting some of the challenges in assessing the economic impact of genomic medicine and the use of advanced (and less advanced) technologies, the book will propose potential solutions to these key challenges. For example, in terms of data availability, one obstacle to translating genomic sequencing into routine health care has been a lack of large randomised controlled clinical trials data for health economists and others to use to populate cost-effectiveness analyses (CEAs). Arguably, in response, reimbursement decisions have moved towards lower evidentiary standards, with the development of managed access programs that hope to balance the intense pressure for patient access with the need to consider the sustainability objectives of health care systems. Single arm trials are common for assessing clinical utility of precision medicine. By excluding a counterfactual, these trials introduce outcomes uncertainty through their inability to establish causal treatment effects. In this section of the book, we illustrate the application of quasi-experimental methods for evaluating precision medicine in case studies linking real-world big data and single arm trials. A further potential option here might be provided by 'big data' can be used to partially support CEAs in genomics. Advanced genomic sequencing is considered to be a prominent example of big data because of the quantity and complexity of data it produces and because it presents an opportunity to use powerful information sources that could reduce clinical and health economic uncertainty at a patient level. The creation of large national sequencing initiatives with sequencing data linked to clinical data (including health outcomes) and resource use data such as hospital episode statistics data and claims data. Large-scale sequencing projects such as the 100,000 Genome Project in the UK and the All of Us Program in the US are collecting an unprecedented amount of genomic, clinical and healthcare resource use data on individuals with cancer or rare diseases, as well as healthy individuals. Some of these large-scale projects are now approaching completion, and national health services are deciding whether WGS and WES should be translated into clinical practice for specific disorders.

Genome-Based Diagnostics

Genome-Based Diagnostics
Author: Institute of Medicine
Publisher: National Academies Press
Total Pages: 104
Release: 2012-06-27
Genre: Medical
ISBN: 0309253977

Download Genome-Based Diagnostics Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

The sequencing of the human genome and the identification of associations between specific genetic variants and diseases have led to an explosion of genomic-based diagnostic tests. These tests have the potential to direct therapeutic interventions, predict risk or onset of disease, or detect residual disease. As research progresses and an increasing number of associations are found, further tests will be developed that can aid in providing personalized treatment options for patients. However, the adoption of genomic diagnostic tests by health care providers has been limited due to a lack of evidence regarding the clinical utility of many tests. Health funders and practitioners lack the data necessary to distinguish which tests can improve practice or the clinical settings in which tests will provide the greatest value. The Roundtable on Translating Genomic-Based Research for Health held a workshop in November 2010 to determine what evidence is needed and how it is viewed by different stakeholders in order to develop genomic diagnostic tests of clinical value. Genome-Based Diagnostics summarizes the presentations and discussions that took place throughout the workshop. Two presentations, in particular, sparked extensive discussion. One presentation proposed that all genomic diagnostic tests be reviewed and approved by the Food and Drug Administration. The other observed that venture capitalists are no longer investing substantially in the development of genomic diagnostic tests because of a lack of clarity surrounding regulatory and reimbursement pathways. Both presentations suggested the need for major changes in the systems used to develop, regulate, and reimburse genomic diagnostic tests. The report also presents the perspectives of different stakeholders in the development of genomic diagnostic tests. Each stakeholder group has a different set of needs and issues of importance, yet commonalities among them are apparent, such as the need to put patients and health outcomes at the center of discussion and action.

Clinical Applications for Next-Generation Sequencing

Clinical Applications for Next-Generation Sequencing
Author: Urszula Demkow
Publisher: Academic Press
Total Pages: 336
Release: 2015-09-10
Genre: Science
ISBN: 0128018410

Download Clinical Applications for Next-Generation Sequencing Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Clinical Applications for Next Generation Sequencing provides readers with an outstanding postgraduate resource to learn about the translational use of NGS in clinical environments. Rooted in both medical genetics and clinical medicine, the book fills the gap between state-of-the-art technology and evidence-based practice, providing an educational opportunity for users to advance patient care by transferring NGS to the needs of real-world patients. The book builds an interface between genetic laboratory staff and clinical health workers to not only improve communication, but also strengthen cooperation. Users will find valuable tactics they can use to build a systematic framework for understanding the role of NGS testing in both common and rare diseases and conditions, from prenatal care, like chromosomal abnormalities, up to advanced age problems like dementia. Fills the gap between state-of-the-art technology and evidence-based practice Provides an educational opportunity which advances patient care through the transfer of NGS to real-world patient assessment Promotes a practical tool that clinicians can apply directly to patient care Includes a systematic framework for understanding the role of NGS testing in many common and rare diseases Presents evidence regarding the important role of NGS in current diagnostic strategies

Evolution of Translational Omics

Evolution of Translational Omics
Author: Institute of Medicine
Publisher: National Academies Press
Total Pages: 354
Release: 2012-09-13
Genre: Science
ISBN: 0309224187

Download Evolution of Translational Omics Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Technologies collectively called omics enable simultaneous measurement of an enormous number of biomolecules; for example, genomics investigates thousands of DNA sequences, and proteomics examines large numbers of proteins. Scientists are using these technologies to develop innovative tests to detect disease and to predict a patient's likelihood of responding to specific drugs. Following a recent case involving premature use of omics-based tests in cancer clinical trials at Duke University, the NCI requested that the IOM establish a committee to recommend ways to strengthen omics-based test development and evaluation. This report identifies best practices to enhance development, evaluation, and translation of omics-based tests while simultaneously reinforcing steps to ensure that these tests are appropriately assessed for scientific validity before they are used to guide patient treatment in clinical trials.

Clinical Genomics

Clinical Genomics
Author: Shashikant Kulkarni
Publisher: Academic Press
Total Pages: 489
Release: 2014-11-10
Genre: Science
ISBN: 0124051731

Download Clinical Genomics Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Clinical Genomics provides an overview of the various next-generation sequencing (NGS) technologies that are currently used in clinical diagnostic laboratories. It presents key bioinformatic challenges and the solutions that must be addressed by clinical genomicists and genomic pathologists, such as specific pipelines for identification of the full range of variants that are clinically important. This book is also focused on the challenges of diagnostic interpretation of NGS results in a clinical setting. Its final sections are devoted to the emerging regulatory issues that will govern clinical use of NGS, and reimbursement paradigms that will affect the way in which laboratory professionals get paid for the testing. Simplifies complexities of NGS technologies for rapid education of clinical genomicists and genomic pathologists towards genomic medicine paradigm Tried and tested practice-based analysis for precision diagnosis and treatment plans Specific pipelines and meta-analysis for full range of clinically important variants