Essays on Mechanism Design and Multiple Privately Informed Principals

Essays on Mechanism Design and Multiple Privately Informed Principals
Author: Nicolás Riquelme
Publisher:
Total Pages: 149
Release: 2019
Genre: Consolidation and merger of corporations
ISBN:

Download Essays on Mechanism Design and Multiple Privately Informed Principals Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

"This dissertation is a collection of three papers studying both theoretical and applied aspects of mechanism design. In Chapter 1, we study competing auctions where each seller has private information about the quality of his object and chooses the reserve price of a second-price auction. Buyers observe the reserve prices and decide which auction to participate in. For a class of primitives, we show that a perfect Bayesian equilibrium exists for any finite market. In any such PBE, higher quality is signaled through higher reserve price at the expense of trade opportunities. But there might be bunching regions causing inefficiencies. In fact, in the large-market limit characterized by a directed search model, the interaction of adverse selection and search frictions entail distortion at the bottom: when either the buyer-seller ratio is sufficiently large or a regularity condition is met, there is no separating PBE in which the lowest-quality seller sets reserve price equal to his opportunity cost. This finding carries over to large finite markets and is consistent with observed behavior in auctions for used cars in UK (Choi, Nesheim and Rasul, 2016). In Chapter 2, we study games where a group of privately informed principals design mechanisms to a common agent. The agent has private information (exogenous) and, after observing principals' mechanisms, may have information (endogenous) about feasible allocations and private information from each principal. Thus, each principal may be interested in designing a mechanism to screen all this information, for which a potentially complicated message space to convey this information might be needed. In this project, we provide sufficient conditions on the agent's payoff such that any equilibrium in this setup has an output-equivalent equilibrium using only mechanisms with simple message spaces (direct mechanisms). Depending on the conditions, we propose two different notions of direct mechanisms and discuss their applicability with some examples. In Chapter 3, we study the design of horizontal merger regulation in a Cournot competition setting, where firms are privately informed about production technology. More specifically, a consumer-surplus-maximizer regulator designs a mechanism which determines whether the merger is blocked or accepted, and sets structural remedies (divestitures). This problem does not have the usual quasi-linear structure commonly assumed in the mechanism design literature. We first characterize incentive-compatible mechanisms and then find the optimal one. The complete information case is also presented as a benchmark. Asymmetric information induces important distortions in regulatory decisions. First, every rejected merge would improve consumer surplus. Second, every merge that decreases consumer surplus would be approved. Lastly, every merge rightly approved would be asked fewer divestitures than the optimal one (under-fixing effect). These results seem consistent with recent empirical evidence on the ineffectiveness of the merger regulation"--Pages vii-viii.

Three Essays on Mechanism Design, Information Design and Collective Decision-making

Three Essays on Mechanism Design, Information Design and Collective Decision-making
Author: Shuguang Zhu
Publisher:
Total Pages: 0
Release: 2018
Genre:
ISBN:

Download Three Essays on Mechanism Design, Information Design and Collective Decision-making Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

This thesis investigates several topics in Microeconomic Theory, with a focus on incorporating information control into mechanism design, checking the robustness of mechanisms, and providing a foundation for inconsistent collective decision-making. This work helps to optimize information transmission and acquisition in organizational communications, advertisement and policy design. It also sheds light on how inconsistent group decisions derive from heterogeneity in group members, and proposes ways to restore efficiency. The thesis consists of three chapters, each of which is self-contained and can be read separately. The first chapter studies a mechanism design environment where the principal has control over the agents' information about a payoff-relevant state. The principal commits to an information disclosure policy where each agent observes a private signal, while the principal directly observes neither the true state nor the signal profile. Examples include (1) assessing whether a new product matches consumers' preferences through their feedback on sample product trials, and (2) gathering intelligence by authorizing investigators to collect various aspects of information. I establish optimality of individually uninformative and aggregately revealing disclosure policy, where (i) each agent obtains no new information about the state after observing any realization of his own signal, but (ii) the principal can nevertheless infer the true state from the agents' reports about their signals. Furthermore, this optimal disclosure policy admits simple and intuitive implementation (such as certain types of blinded experiments, or restrictions on access to certain information) under additional assumptions. If attention is restricted to linear settings, I characterize a class of environments (including those satisfying the standard regularity conditions in mechanism design) where an equivalence result holds between private disclosure and public disclosure.The second chapter, co-authored with Takuro Yamashita, is motivated by Chung and Ely (2007), who establish maxmin and Bayesian foundations for dominant-strategy mechanisms in private-value auction environments. We first show that similar foundation results for ex post mechanisms hold true even with interdependent values if the interdependence is only cardinal. Conversely, if the environment exhibits ordinal interdependence, which is typically the case with multi-dimensional environments, then in general, ex post mechanisms do not have foundation. That is, there exists a non-ex-post mechanism that achieves strictly higher expected revenue than the optimal ex post mechanism, regardless of the agents' high-order beliefs. The third chapter shows that dynamic inconsistency in collective decision-making can derive from heterogeneity in group members' outside options (i.e. opportunity costs that individuals have to pay in order to join the group), even if individuals share the same exponentially discounting time preference. This model of endogenous dynamic inconsistency facilitatesthe analysis of welfare consequences, since time-consistent individual preferences allow for a well-defined measurement of social welfare. We further characterize the optimal Bayesian persuasion information disclosure policy, which takes the form of upper revealing rules, to alleviate the welfare distortion caused by inconsistent collective decisions. Our framework proves to be highly adaptable to various contexts, including provision of public facilities and assignment on team work.

Essays in Mechanism Design

Essays in Mechanism Design
Author: Yunan Li
Publisher:
Total Pages: 594
Release: 2017
Genre:
ISBN:

Download Essays in Mechanism Design Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

In this thesis, I study mechanism design problems in environments where the information necessary to make decisions is affected by the actions of principal or agents.The first chapter considers the problem of a principal who must allocate a good among a finite number of agents, each of whom values the good. Each agent has private information about the principal's payoff if he receives the good. There are no monetary transfers. The principal can inspect agents' reports at a cost and punish them, but punishments are limited because verification is imperfect or information arrives only after the good has been allocated for a while. I characterize an optimal mechanism featuring two thresholds. Agents whose values are below the lower threshold and above the upper threshold are pooled, respectively. If the number of agents is small, then the pooling area at the top of value distribution disappears. If the number of agents is large, then the two pooling areas meet and the optimal mechanism can be implemented via a shortlisting procedure. The fact that the optimal mechanism depends on the number of agents implies that small and large organizations should behave differently. The second chapter considers the problem of a principal who wishes to distribute an indivisible good to a population of budget-constrained agents. Both valuation and budget are an agent's private information. The principal can inspect an agent's budget through a costly verification process and punish an agent who makes a false statement. I characterize the direct surplus-maximizing mechanism. This direct mechanism can be implemented by a two-stage mechanism in which agents only report their budgets. Specifically, all agents report their budgets in the first stage. The principal then provides budget-dependent cash subsidies to agents and assigns the goods randomly (with uniform probability) at budget-dependent prices. In the second stage, a resale market opens, but is regulated with budget-dependent sales taxes. Agents who report low budgets receive more subsidies in their initial purchases (the first stage), face higher taxes in the resale market (the second stage) and are inspected randomly. This implementation exhibits some of the features of some welfare programs, such as Singapore's housing and development board.The third chapter studies the design of ex-ante efficient mechanisms in situations where a single item is for sale, and agents have positively interdependent values and can covertly acquire information at a cost before participating in a mechanism. I find that when interdependency is low or the number of agents is large, the ex-post efficient mechanism is also ex-ante efficient. In cases of high interdependency or a small number of agents, ex-ante efficient mechanisms discourage agents from acquiring excessive information by introducing randomization to the ex-post efficient allocation rule in areas where the information's precision increases most rapidly.

Bayesian Implementation

Bayesian Implementation
Author: Thomas R. Palfrey
Publisher: CRC Press
Total Pages: 126
Release: 2020-08-26
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 1000154645

Download Bayesian Implementation Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

The implementation problem lies at the heart of a theory of institutions. Simply stated, the aim of implementation theory is to investigate in a rigorous way the relationships between outcomes in a society and how those outcomes arise. The first part of "Bayesian Implementation" presents a basic model of the Bayesian implementation problem and summarizes and explains recent developments in this branch of implementation theory. Substantive problems of interest such as public goods provision, auctions and bargaining are special cases of the model, and these are addressed in subsequent chapters.

Advances in Economic Theory: Volume 1

Advances in Economic Theory: Volume 1
Author: Econometric Society. World Congress
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Total Pages: 342
Release: 1992
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 9780521484596

Download Advances in Economic Theory: Volume 1 Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

This book gives the reader a unique survey of advances in economic theory.

Essays On Mechanism Design Without Transfers

Essays On Mechanism Design Without Transfers
Author: Ethem Akyol
Publisher:
Total Pages:
Release: 2014
Genre:
ISBN:

Download Essays On Mechanism Design Without Transfers Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

This dissertation consists of three chapters.In Chapter 1, we compare two widely used allocation methods for school choice, the Deferred Acceptance (DA) mechanism and the Boston mechanism, in terms of welfare. We consider a symmetric incomplete information setting in which students have independently drawn valuations for schools and all schools have an identical ranking of the students. Our main result is that when each school has one available seat and the number of schools and students is large, every type of every student has a higher interim utility under the Boston mechanism than under the DA mechanism. Although this strong result is not true when the number of schools is small, even in this case, the Boston mechanism is ex-ante welfare superior to DA under weak conditions on the distribution of valuations.In Chapter 2, we consider the problem of allocating n>=2 indivisible distinct objects (possibly with multiple copies of each) to m>=2 agents without monetary transfers. We assume that agents have private preferences and consider mechanisms that depend only on agents' reported ordinal preferences. Full efficiency cannot be achieved in this environment, and so we look for a welfare maximizing, incentive compatible mechanism. We show that when agents' rankings over objects are independent of other agents' rankings and each possible ranking is equally likely, the so-called Ranking mechanism (first-order) stochastically dominates any other anonymous, neutral and incentive compatible ordinal mechanism. In particular, when agents' preferences over random allocations are responsive, every type of every agent has a higher interim welfare under the Ranking mechanism.In Chapter 3, we consider the problem of allocating multiple objects to agents via an auction by using "points" as in the "Course Bidding System" that is used by several business schools. Each agent has a fixed amount of divisible points which can only be used for bidding and have no monetary value. Agents simultaneously bid for the objects, and each object is given to the agent who bids highest for that object. This game is equivalent to the classical "Colonel Blotto" game. We consider this game under incomplete information when agents have private values for the objects. For a class of value distributions, we solve for a Bayes-Nash equilibrium of this game. Furthermore, for all the value distributions for which we can solve for equilibrium in closed form, we show that every type of agent has a higher interim payoff under this allocation method than any other incentive compatible allocation method that depends only on ordinal preferences.

Handbook of Game Theory with Economic Applications

Handbook of Game Theory with Economic Applications
Author: R.J. Aumann
Publisher: Elsevier
Total Pages: 824
Release: 1992
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 9780444894274

Download Handbook of Game Theory with Economic Applications Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

This is the second of three volumes surveying the state of the art in Game Theory and its applications to many and varied fields, in particular to economics. The chapters in the present volume are contributed by outstanding authorities, and provide comprehensive coverage and precise statements of the main results in each area. The applications include empirical evidence. The following topics are covered: communication and correlated equilibria, coalitional games and coalition structures, utility and subjective probability, common knowledge, bargaining, zero-sum games, differential games, and applications of game theory to signalling, moral hazard, search, evolutionary biology, international relations, voting procedures, social choice, public economics, politics, and cost allocation. This handbook will be of interest to scholars in economics, political science, psychology, mathematics and biology. For more information on the Handbooks in Economics series, please see our home page on http://www.elsevier.nl/locate/hes