Essays on Environmental Regulations in Electricity Markets

Essays on Environmental Regulations in Electricity Markets
Author: Yanming Sun
Publisher:
Total Pages: 102
Release: 2013
Genre:
ISBN:

Download Essays on Environmental Regulations in Electricity Markets Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Reducing the Greenhouse Gas pollution and promoting energy efficiency among consumers' energy use have been major public policy issues recently. Currently, both the United States and the European Union have set up explicit percentage requirements that require energy generators or consumers to undertake a certain percentage of their energy production or consumption from renewable sources. To achieve their renewable targets, the Tradable Green Certificates (TGC) system has been introduced in their electricity markets. Moreover, in order to promote energy conservation and achieve energy efficiency targets, price policies and price changes derived from environmental regulations have played a more important role in reducing electricity consumption. My research studies problems associated with these policy implementations. In Chapter 1, I analyze a competitive electricity market with two countries operated under a common TGC system. By using geometric illustrations, I compare the two countries' welfare when the renewable quota is chosen optimally under the common certificate market with three different situations. The policy recommendation is that when the value of damage parameter is sufficiently small, full integration with a TGC market is welfare superior to full integration of an all fossil-fuel based market with an optimal emissions standard. In Chapter 2, by analyzing a stylized theoretical model and numerical examples, I investigate the performance of the optimal renewables policy under full separation and full integration scenarios for two countries' electricity markets operated under TGC systems. In my third chapter, I look at residential electricity consumption responsiveness to increases of electricity price in the U.S. and the different effect of a price increase on electricity use for states of different income levels. My analysis reveals that raising the energy price in the short run will not give consumers much incentive to adjust their appliances and make energy conservation investments to reduce electricity use, while in the long run, consumers are more likely to lower their electricity consumption, facing the higher electricity price induced from regulation policies. In addition, for states of higher per capita GDP, raising the electricity price may be more effective to ensure a cut in electricity consumption.

Essays on Environmental Policy in Energy Markets

Essays on Environmental Policy in Energy Markets
Author: Judson Paul Boomhower
Publisher:
Total Pages: 143
Release: 2015
Genre:
ISBN:

Download Essays on Environmental Policy in Energy Markets Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Producing and consuming energy involves costly environmental externalities, which are addressed through a wide range of public policy interventions. This dissertation examines three economic questions that are important to environmental regulation in energy. The first chapter measures the effect of bankruptcy protection on industry structure and environmental outcomes in oil and gas extraction. The second chapter measures additionality in an appliance replacement rebate program. Finally, the third chapter focuses on the environmental impacts of subsidizing electricity production from forest-derived biomass fuels. The first chapter measures the incentive effect of limited liability. When liability is limited by bankruptcy, theory says that firms will take excessive environmental and public health risks. In the long run, this ``judgment-proof problem'' may increase the share of small producers, even when there are economies of scale. I use quasi-experimental variation in liability exposure to measure the effects of bankruptcy protection on industry structure and environmental outcomes in oil and gas extraction. Using firm-level data on the universe of Texas oil and gas producers, I examine the introduction of an insurance mandate that reduced firms' ability to avoid liability through bankruptcy. The policy was introduced via a quasi-randomized rollout, which allows me to cleanly identify its effects on industry structure. The insurance requirement pushed about 6% of producers out of the market immediately. The exiting firms were primarily small and were more likely to have poor environmental records. Among firms that remained in business, the bond requirement reduced oil production among the smallest 80% of firms by about 4% on average, which is consistent with increased internalization of environmental costs. Production by the largest 20% of firms, which account for the majority of total production, was unaffected. Finally, environmental outcomes, including those related to groundwater contamination, also improved sharply. These results suggest that incomplete internalization of environmental and safety costs due to bankruptcy protection is an important determinant of industry structure and safety effort in hazardous industries, with significant welfare consequences. The second chapter focuses on the importance of a regulator's inability to distinguish between households responding to a subsidy, and households doing what they would also have done in the absence of policy. Economists have long argued that many recipients of energy-efficiency subsidies may be ``non-additional, '' getting paid to do what they would have done anyway. Demonstrating this empirically has been difficult, however, because of endogeneity concerns and other challenges. In this paper we use a regression discontinuity analysis to examine participation in a large-scale residential energy-efficiency program. Comparing behavior just on either side of several eligibility thresholds, we find that program participation increases with larger subsidy amounts, but that most households would have participated even with much lower subsidy amounts. The large fraction of inframarginal participants means that the larger subsidy amounts are almost certainly not cost-effective. Moreover, the results imply that about half of all participants would have adopted the energy-efficient technology even with no subsidy whatsoever. Finally, the third chapter addresses consequences of renewable energy subsidies in other markets. Electricity generated from logging residues provides a large and growing share of US renewable electricity generation. Much of the low-value wood used by biomass power plants might otherwise be left in the field. This increased harvest can negatively affect forest health. I investigate the supply of woody biomass fuel in Maine using a 15-year panel of prices and quantities for whole tree wood chips. I find that doubling the price of woody biomass increases harvest by about 64%. I also find that coal prices are a major determinant of woody biomass harvest. This suggests that environmental policies that raise the price of coal will affect forest health.

Hard NO[subscript X]

Hard NO[subscript X]
Author: Kevin Nakolan
Publisher:
Total Pages:
Release: 2020
Genre:
ISBN:

Download Hard NO[subscript X] Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

This dissertation focuses on understanding the private and social impacts of environmental policies amid the diverse landscape of the U.S. electricity sector. Many of the environmental policies we employ today are grounded in economic theory. In theory, these programs are efficient, allowing us to achieve a desired environmental outcome at the lowest possible cost to society. Unfortunately, however, it is exceedingly rare for markets to conform to the ideal standards by which these theories are based. The U.S. electricity sector is a prime example of this. Our national electricity markets are rife with what we could consider to be market imperfections. These imperfections often influence the performance of our environmental policies, leading to unintended and potentially detrimental environmental and societal outcomes. This dissertation consists of three essays that focus on various environmental policies in place within the U.S. electricity sector, and how imperfections in the electricity market shape the performance of said policies. Chapter 2 focuses on a cap and trade program for nitrogen oxide emissions in the eastern United States known as the NO[subscript x] Budget Trading Program (NBP). While the NBP undoubtedly led to significant reductions in nitrogen oxide emissions, current estimates of the program's performance may be overstated, as they fail to account for exogenous trends in emissions rates. Additionally, the means by which these emissions reductions were achieved is unclear. In this chapter, I use daily emissions and generation data for fossil fuel units in the NBP region to re-evaluate the efficacy of the program, and to identify how this abatement was achieved. I find the NBP led to a 50% drop in emissions, relative to a counterfactual estimate, with over 70% of these reductions achieved through falling emissions intensity at existing fossil fuel generators. Chapter 3 also focuses on the NBP, building upon the results from Chapter 2. Declining emissions rates in the NBP can be largely attributed to operation of emissions control technology. This chapter analyzes whether or not electricity generators are operating this technology efficiently with regard to the price incentives created by the cap and trade program (i.e. pollution permits, or lack thereof). Consistent with long-standing IO literature, I find that regulations on retail electricity rates fail to incentivize cost-minimizing behavior from electricity generators, leading generators to overuse expensive technology when complying with program. I show that overuse of this technology is often not beneficial, with the private cost of operating the technology often outweighing its environmental benefits, and may be creating even more detrimental effects under current cap and trade programs. Chapter 4 investigates the impact of growing solar generating capacity on air pollution outcomes in California. California has experienced an explosive growth in solar generating capacity over the last decade, and is anticipated to grow even further in coming years. Recent literature has shown that this growth in solar generating capacity has led to an increase in generation from relatively dirty fossil fuel generators during the early morning and later afternoon, when demand for electricity is high and solar generating capabilities are low. This chapter considers the local air pollution damages associated with this increase in fossil fuel generation and, more importantly, whether or not these damages are disproportionately affecting more susceptible parts of the state.

Essays on Regulations in the Electricity Industry

Essays on Regulations in the Electricity Industry
Author: Yaran Jin
Publisher:
Total Pages: 288
Release: 2017
Genre:
ISBN:

Download Essays on Regulations in the Electricity Industry Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

In this dissertation, I study the welfare consequences of environmental and price regulations in the electricity industry. I address two important questions. One is that what are the welfare consequences of allowing firms to self-select between different types of environmental regulations. Another is how does the choice of transmission congestion pricing structure affect the emission externalities and fuel efficiency in the wholesale markets. I answer these questions by exploring several policy experiments in the state of Texas in the United States. The first chapter is a general introduction to the Texas electricity industry and the conceptual framework of analysis in this dissertation. It consists of the institutional details of the industry, including market organizations, transmission congestion pricing structures, and emission regulations. Based on the institutional details, I discuss the theoretical implications and propose the empirical hypothesis for above research questions. In the second chapter, I evaluate the welfare consequences of allowing firms to self-select between cap-and-trade regulation and intensity standards using the data from a unique voluntary NO [subscript x] emission cap-and-trade program in Texas from 2001 to 2005. The welfare evaluation focuses on the effects of such mixed policy instruments on emissions, industry profits, and market exit. I construct and estimate a structural model of power generating units equilibrium choices of policy instrument, emission abatement, and production to recover their abatement costs. With the estimated parameters, I simulate the equilibrium outcomes under a counterfactual mandatory cap-and-trade regulation. Results reveal that the mixed policy framework mainly benefits small and high-cost generating units. However, the aggregate emissions are lower and the aggregate profits are higher under the mandatory cap-and-trade regulation. I also document that the mixed policy instruments lead to a higher exit rate of older generating units. In the year 2010, the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) changed from a zonal market structure to a nodal market structure to incorporate the cost of transmission congestion into the wholesale price. The third chapter compares the emission intensities and fuel efficiency of power generating units in the ERCOT before and after this regulatory change, to investigate its efficiency and environmental impacts in the congested areas. I find that the new nodal market structure has heterogeneous impacts on areas with different causes of transmission congestion. For counties located along the path to transferring wind generation from west Texas to east Texas, the nodal pricing leads to increases in emissions from fossil-fired power plants, although the total increase in emission cost is not economically significant. Contrarily, the nodal pricing increases the fuel efficiency by 2-9.6% for power plants located around congested areas with excess load, and the estimated fuel cost saving is around $154.8m. The results provide important policy implications for future transmission network planning.

The Regulation of Power Exchanges in Europe

The Regulation of Power Exchanges in Europe
Author: Martha M. Roggenkamp
Publisher: Intersentia nv
Total Pages: 338
Release: 2005
Genre: Electric power distribution
ISBN: 9050953174

Download The Regulation of Power Exchanges in Europe Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

The liberalisation of the electricity sector has changed the way in which electricity is traded. De facto or legal vertical monopolies are gradually abandoned and new participants have entered the market. At the wholesale level, one of the important developments is the establishment of organised electricity markets, i.e. electricity power exchanges. This book analyses the role and evaluates the impact of these new organised markets, which until now received little attention. The introduction provides an overview of the developments on EC level as this creates the legal environment within which power exchanges operate. The implementation of the EC Electricity Directive has inter alia resulted in a commodization of electricity trading. Thereupon the development of power pools and electricity exchanges is discussed as well as the products which can be traded. Subsequently, the development of the most important national and/or regional exchanges in Europe will be examined. National experts will analyse the role of power exchanges in the Nordic countries, the United Kingdom, the Netherlands, Germany, France, Austria, Spain and Italy. The authors analyse the most important developments in their jurisdictions according to a fixed outline (e.g. implementation of the EC Electricity Directive, market structure, emergence and functioning of the organised market, products traded and the impact of cross-border trade) which allows for a comparative analysis and facilitates understanding. Finally, some conclusions with regard to the establishment of a single electricity market will be presented as well as some future developments.

Pollution Under Environmental Regulation in Energy Markets

Pollution Under Environmental Regulation in Energy Markets
Author: Francesco Gullì
Publisher: Springer Science & Business Media
Total Pages: 124
Release: 2012-12-14
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 1447147278

Download Pollution Under Environmental Regulation in Energy Markets Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Pollution Under Environmental Regulation in Energy Markets provides a study of environmental regulation when energy markets are imperfectly competitive. This theoretical treatment focuses on three relevant cases of energy markets. First, the residential space heating sector where hybrid regulation such as taxation and emissions trading together are possible. Second, the electricity market where transactions are organized in the form of multi-period auctions. Third, namely natural gas (input) and electricity (output) markets where there is combined imperfect competition in vertical related energy markets. The development of free or low carbon technologies supported by energy policies, aiming at increasing security of supply, is also explored whilst considering competition policies that reduce market power in energy markets thus improving market efficiency. Pollution Under Environmental Regulation in Energy Markets discusses the key issues of whether imperfect competition can lessen the ability of environmental policy to reduce pollution and/or to minimize the cost of meeting environmental targets. Policymakers, analysts and researchers gain a thorough understanding of the performance of environmental policy from Pollution Under Environmental Regulation in Energy Markets leading to better design of simulation models of performance and costs of environmental regulation.

Essays on Regulation, Liberalization and Privatization in Energy Markets

Essays on Regulation, Liberalization and Privatization in Energy Markets
Author: Carlos Suárez
Publisher:
Total Pages: 174
Release: 2020
Genre:
ISBN:

Download Essays on Regulation, Liberalization and Privatization in Energy Markets Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

"The general motivation of this research is to explore the effects of the coexistence of public and private companies on the allocative efficiency of the supply of electricity. In particular, this thesis investigates from an empirical perspective to what extent the distinction between private and public companies is relevant to understand the competition in the wholesale electricity generation markets. I apply several econometric techniques and theory advances in industrial organization branch on data of the firms of the Colombian market. The case of the Colombian electricity market is suitable to study this issues for four reasons: i) It is an oligopoly in which private and public companies compete under the same rules. ii) The most important firms in the Colombian electricity sector are mature organizations, with a conventional business vision. In fact, many of these companies belong to transnational capital that carry out activities in several continents. iii) The market setting have a conventional design similar to other liberalized electricity markets. It operates as a multi-unit uniform-price auction. iv) There is available information with daily and even hourly resolution of the generation market variables. I consider that these are key elements for justifying the external validity of the results. This thesis presents three essays that aim to answer three questions related to the interaction between competition in electricity markets and their ownership structure. Chapter 1 addresses the question: Do the switch from public to private management have impacts in the bidding strategy of specific generation assets? Chapter 2 explores the question: Do public and private generation companies respond the same to the incentives to relax competition? Chapter 3 focuses on the question: Do private companies have a greater propensity to establish coordination relationships in comparison to public firms? In the first chapter of this thesis I evaluate the impact of privatization on the bidding of electricity units participating in a liberalized wholesale electricity market. The results of this evaluation contribute to better understand whether privatization is the right decision in an environment of imperfect competition. In this essay I adopt a policy evaluation approach to estimate the impact of changes from public to private management on the bidding prices of electricity generation units. I use information of bidding prices of the Colombian wholesale electricity market and exploit the changes of management of generation units documented in the period 2006 - 2018. The methodologies and results presented in this thesis contributes to the literature of mixed oligopoly because they place special emphasis on the behavioral differences between private and public companies and studies a field experience in which they compete in the same relevant market. The empirical evidence resultant from the policy evaluation method is aligned with the theoretical predictions of comparative statics arising from the behavioral differences of mixed oligopoly models. The second chapter of this dissertation proposes a methodology in order to find differences between the reactions of private and public firms when they face incentives to exercises unilateral market power. Several common events in the electricity industry such as transmission restrictions, the concentration of generation property within specific areas, the non-storage capacity of electricity and the low elasticity of demand, provide opportunities to exert market power. That is why this issue has been widely studied and discussed theoretically and empirically. The novel element of this essay in relation to this strand of the literature is accounting for the distinction between private and public companies regarding competitive behavior. Chapter 3 investigates from an empirical perspective the role of disclosure information in the stability of informal coordination agreements. Particularly, this chapter focuses in the economic effects of the announcement and the put into effect of a non-transparency policy implemented in the Colombian wholesale electricity market in 2009. We propose an identification strategy for isolating the effect of a coordinating relation from the confusion factors related with unilateral market power. The characteristics of the reform of the transparency policy allow to link the simple announcement of the policy change with the collapse of a coordinated strategy of private firms in a repeated interaction context. We use several empirical tools to assess the impact of the simple announcement of a modification in the transparency conditions on the average bidding price of private firms. We present an empirical analysis of the average bidding price data over August 2008 - July 2009. Overall, the evidence presented in the three essays of this dissertation indicates that the distinction between public and private companies may be a relevant aspect for explaining the functioning of competition in liberalized industries." -- TDX.

Essays on Regulatory Impact in Electricity and Internet Markets

Essays on Regulatory Impact in Electricity and Internet Markets
Author: Thomas Edward Roderick
Publisher:
Total Pages: 264
Release: 2014
Genre:
ISBN:

Download Essays on Regulatory Impact in Electricity and Internet Markets Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

This dissertation details regulation's impact in networked markets, notably in deregulated electricity and internet service markets. These markets represent basic infrastructure in the modern economy; their innate networked structures make for rich fields of economic research on regulatory impact. The first chapter models deregulated electricity industries with a focus on the Texas market. Optimal economic benchmarks are considered for markets with regulated delivery and interrelated network costs. Using a model of regulator, consumer, and firm interaction, I determine the efficiency of the current rate formalization compared to Ramsey-Boiteux prices and two-part tariffs. I find within Texas's market increases to generator surplus up to 55% of subsidies could be achieved under Ramsey-Boiteux pricing or two-part tariffs, respectively. The second chapter presents a framework to analyze dynamic processes and long-run outcomes in two-sided markets, specifically dynamic platform and firm investment incentives within the internet-service platform/content provision market. I use the Ericson-Pakes framework applied within a platform that chooses fees on either side of its two-sided market. This chapter determines the impact of network neutrality on platform investment incentives, specifically whether to improve the platform. I use a parameterized calibration from engineering reports and current ISP literature to determine welfare outcomes and industry behavior under network neutral and non-neutral regimes. My final chapter explores retail firm failure within the deregulated Texas retail electricity market. This chapter investigates determinants of retail electric firm failures using duration analysis frameworks. In particular, this chapter investigates the impact of these determinants on firms with extant experience versus unsophisticated entrants. Understanding these determinants is an important component in evaluating whether deregulation achieves the impetus of competitive electricity market restructuring. Knowing which economic events decrease a market's competitiveness helps regulators to effectively evaluate policy implementations. I find that experience does benefit a firm's duration, but generally that benefit assists firm duration in an adverse macroeconomic environment rather than in response to adverse market conditions such as higher wholesale prices or increased transmission congestion. Additionally, I find evidence that within the Texas market entering earlier results in a longer likelihood of duration.

Electricity Restructuring

Electricity Restructuring
Author: John Carlson
Publisher: Nova Publishers
Total Pages: 152
Release: 2002
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 9781590332214

Download Electricity Restructuring Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Five essays examine issues of restructuring of electricity markets and regulations. The authors generally acknowledge that total deregulation could have disastrous consequences and promote a hybrid restructuring that takes into account certain concerns related to air pollution and consumer rights. Also included are abstracts of 18 journal papers on the same topic. Annotation copyrighted by Book News, Inc., Portland, OR