Communication Strategies for Engaging Climate Skeptics

Communication Strategies for Engaging Climate Skeptics
Author: Emma Frances Bloomfield
Publisher: Routledge
Total Pages: 182
Release: 2019-05-10
Genre: Political Science
ISBN: 0429998368

Download Communication Strategies for Engaging Climate Skeptics Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Communication Strategies for Engaging Climate Skeptics examines the intersection of climate skepticism and Christianity and proposes strategies for engaging climate skeptics in productive conversations. Despite the scientifically established threats of climate change, there remains a segment of the American population that is skeptical of the scientific consensus on climate change and the urgent need for action. One of the most important stakeholders and conversants in environmental conversations is the religious community. While existing studies have discussed environmentalism as a factor within the religious community, this book positions religion as an important factor in environmentalism and focuses on how identities play a role in environmental conversation. Rather than thinking of religious skeptics as a single unified group, Emma Frances Bloomfield argues that it is essential to recognize there are different types of skeptics so that we can better tailor our communication strategies to engage with them on issues of the environment and climate change. To do so, this work breaks skeptics down into three main types: "separators," "bargainers," and "harmonizers." The book questions monolithic understandings of climate skepticism and considers how competing narratives such as religion, economics, and politics play a large role in climate communication. Considering recent political moves to remove climate change from official records and withdraw from international environmental agreements, it is imperative now more than ever to offer practical solutions to academics, practitioners, and the public to change the conversation. To address these concerns, this book provides both a theoretical examination of the rhetoric of religious climate skeptics and concrete strategies for engaging the religious community in conversations about the environment. This book will be of great interest to students, scholars, and practitioners of climate change science, environmental communication, environmental policy, and religion.

Science v. Story

Science v. Story
Author: Emma Frances Bloomfield
Publisher: Univ of California Press
Total Pages: 287
Release: 2024-02-27
Genre: Science
ISBN: 0520380835

Download Science v. Story Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Uncovering common threads across types of science skepticism to show why these controversial narratives stick and how we can more effectively counter them through storytelling Science v. Story analyzes four scientific controversies—climate change, evolution, vaccination, and COVID-19—through the lens of storytelling. Instead of viewing stories as adversaries to scientific practices, Emma Frances Bloomfield demonstrates how storytelling is integral to science communication. Drawing from narrative theory and rhetorical studies, Science v. Story examines scientific stories and rival stories, including disingenuous rival stories that undermine scientific conclusions and productive rival stories that work to make science more inclusive. Science v. Story offers two tools to evaluate and build stories: narrative webs and narrative constellations. These visual mapping tools chart the features of a story (i.e., characters, action, sequence, scope, storyteller, and content) to locate opportunities for audience engagement. Bloomfield ultimately argues that we can strengthen science communication by incorporating storytelling in critical ways that are attentive to audience and context.

Rational Climate Skeptics

Rational Climate Skeptics
Author: Youngseok Park
Publisher:
Total Pages: 31
Release: 2017
Genre:
ISBN:

Download Rational Climate Skeptics Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

This paper presents a game-theoretical approach to climate change skeptics. The credibility gap between the scientist and the government is created if the preference of the scientist is not perfectly aligned with that of the government. The credibility gap is eliminated and the ex-ante social welfare is maximized if and only if the scientist's preference is perfectly aligned with that of the government, not with that of the median voter. This is endogenously achieved when the government is allowed to appoint its optimal scientist without election concerns. In the case where the government has election concerns, if the median voter perceives an alarming message from the scientist, then even a “right-wing” government must choose an aggressive climate change policy to avoid losing the election. Accordingly, it will prefer to appoint a scientist who is unlikely to send an alarming message. Thus the government deliberately creates a credibility gap which may cause a distorted climate change policy in a democracy.

Disruptive Environmental Communication

Disruptive Environmental Communication
Author: Christian A. Klöckner
Publisher: Springer Nature
Total Pages: 166
Release: 2022-11-11
Genre: Psychology
ISBN: 3031171659

Download Disruptive Environmental Communication Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

This book proposes a radical change in communication strategies about environmental problems, advocating for more active and emotionally engaging methods that drive people to action. Based on new theoretical developments and research, the book provides a new framework for designing such communication strategies and suggests practical implementations of these ideas for practitioners, policy-makers, and scientists. Among the topics discussed: • The psychology of change and why disruptive communication is necessary • Virtual reality technologies used to communicate complex ideas • Reflections on the value of science fiction and climate fiction in addressing environmental issues • Analyzing the impact of youth climate activism Disruptive Environmental Communication provides an innovative new framework for designing effective communication strategies to address large-scale environmental problems, challenging the assumption that environmental problems can be communicated and handled through non-disruptive methods.

To Believe Or Not to Believe? The Influence of Political Communication on the Beliefs of Climate Change Skeptics in the United States

To Believe Or Not to Believe? The Influence of Political Communication on the Beliefs of Climate Change Skeptics in the United States
Author: Aditi Vaishali Thapar
Publisher:
Total Pages: 0
Release: 2022
Genre: Climatic changes
ISBN:

Download To Believe Or Not to Believe? The Influence of Political Communication on the Beliefs of Climate Change Skeptics in the United States Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Climate change, also referred to as global warming, is one of the defining challenges of the 21st century. Despite considerable evidence that climate change is occurring and has severe consequences, many Americans remain skeptical and are impeding efforts to address the problem. The purpose of this dissertation is to build an understanding of the determinants of climate change perceptions among climate skeptics. Specifically, this research explores the extent to which political communication affects climate skeptics’ perceptions of the phenomenon. In total, three separate analyses were conducted using a national sample of climate skeptics (N = 4,001). The first analysis provides a profile of the average climate skeptic. Using descriptive data and responses from an open-ended question, the study provides a bird’s-eye view of the factors that might contribute to individual perceptions of climate change. The findings confirm those of existing research; particularly that climate skepticism is more prevalent among Republicans, older populations, low-income individuals, and those who identify as evangelical. Individuals report being skeptical of climate change because they believe that the narrative around climate change only advances the interests of elites. Individuals also cite factors such as media coverage, awareness of historical data, first-hand experiences with local weather, knowledge of the phenomenon (or lack thereof), and belief in a higher power as reasons for their climate skepticism. The second analysis employs a randomized survey experiment to examine whether framing climate messages as optimistic or fatalistic (i.e., the phenomenon is unstoppable by human action) affects the perceptions of climate skeptics (N = 827). The results show that the framing of an issue does not influence climate skeptics’ beliefs that (1) climate change is occurring or (2) that the phenomenon poses a risk of personal harm. Partisanship, however, does appear to moderate the relationship between message framing and support for adaptation and mitigation policy measures. In particular, Republican climate skeptics who receive optimistically framed messages about the impacts of existing adaptation and mitigation measures tend to increase their support for climate policy. The third analysis employs a randomized survey experiment to examine whether the identity of a political actor delivering climate change information (namely, their name and partisan affiliation) influences the beliefs of climate skeptics (N = 3,174). The findings show that climate skeptics are likely to increase their belief that (1) climate change is occurring and (2) climate change is anthropogenic when presented with messages from prominent public officials that share their partisan affiliation, particularly among Republicans. These effects are more pronounced when the participant voted for the identified public official. Additionally, high trust in a named messenger (e.g., Donald Trump) led to a greater belief that the phenomenon is (1) occurring and (2) caused by humans than high trust in an unnamed messenger (e.g., Congressional Republicans). The analyses also reveal a strong “Trump effect”, where Republican climate skeptics who received messages attributed to Donald Trump increased their climate beliefs to a greater extent than their counterparts in the other treatment groups. The analyses presented in this dissertation show that climate skeptics are open to updating their beliefs about the phenomenon. While existing research has studied the impacts of framing and identity on individual beliefs of climate change, few studies have examined how different political communication approaches might affect an individual’s perceptions of climate change. Even fewer studies focus solely on climate skeptics. My contribution to the field is a nuanced understanding of the average climate skeptic’s psyche and decision-making processes as it pertains to updating their climate beliefs. Tailored climate communication efforts by policymakers and public leaders can bridge the knowledge gap between scientists and communities. Decision-makers can leverage these findings to increase public support for pro-environmental policies and the uptake of climate-smart interventions.

The Routledge Handbook of Environment and Communication

The Routledge Handbook of Environment and Communication
Author: Anders Hansen
Publisher: Taylor & Francis
Total Pages: 661
Release: 2022-12-26
Genre: Political Science
ISBN: 1000787346

Download The Routledge Handbook of Environment and Communication Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

This revised and fully updated second edition of the Routledge Handbook of Environment and Communication provides a state-of-the-art overview of environmental communication theory, practice and research. The momentous changes witnessed in the politics of the environment as well as in the nature of media and public communication in recent years have made the study and understanding of environmental communication ever more pertinent. This is reflected in this second edition, including a number of exciting new chapters concerned with: environmental communication in an age of misinformation and fake news; environmental communication, community and social transformation; environmental justice; and advances in methods for the analysis of mediated environmental communication.Signalling the key dimensions of public mediated communication, the Handbook is organised around five thematic parts: the history and development of the field of environmental communication research, the sources, communicators and media professionals involved in producing environmental communication, research on news, entertainment media and wider cultural representations of the environment, the social and political implications of environmental communication, and the likely future trajectories for the field. Written by leading scholars in the field, this authoritative text is a must for scholars and students of environmental communication across multiple subject areas, including environmental studies, media and communication studies, cultural studies and related disciplines.

The Power of Narrative

The Power of Narrative
Author: Raul P. Lejano
Publisher: Oxford University Press
Total Pages:
Release: 2020-09-18
Genre: Language Arts & Disciplines
ISBN: 0197542115

Download The Power of Narrative Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

There is an ideological war of words waging in America, one that speaks to a new fundamentalism rising not just within the American public, but across other ideologically-torn nations around the globe as well. At its heart is climate skepticism, an ideological watershed that has become a core belief for millions of people despite a large scientific consensus supporting the science of anthropogenic climate change. While many scholars have examined the role of lobbyists and conservative think tanks in fueling the climate skepticism movement, there has not yet been a systematic analysis of why the narrative itself has resonated so powerfully with the public. Pulling from science and technology studies, narrative and discourse theory, and public policy, The Power of Narrative examines the strength of climate skepticism as a story, offering a thoughtful analysis and comparison of anti-climate science narratives over time and across geographic boundaries. This book provides fresh insight into the rhetorical and semantic properties on both sides of the climate change debate that preclude dialogue around climate science, and proposes a means for moving beyond ideological entrenchment through language mediation, further ethnographic study, and research-informed teaching. The Power of Narrative culminates in the revelation of a parallel between narratives about climate skepticism and those in other issue areas (e.g., gun rights, immigration, health crises), exposing a genetic meta-narrative of public distrust and isolation. Ultimately, The Power of Narrative is not a book about climate change in itself: it is, instead, a book about how our society understands and interacts with science, how a social narrative becomes ideology, and how we can move beyond personal and political dogma to arrive at a sense of collective rapprochement.

Communication Strategies for Earning Trust in Climate Change Debates

Communication Strategies for Earning Trust in Climate Change Debates
Author:
Publisher:
Total Pages:
Release: 2013
Genre:
ISBN:

Download Communication Strategies for Earning Trust in Climate Change Debates Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Abstract Climate scientists need the trust of lay audiences if they are to share their knowledge. But significant audience segments—those doubtful or dismissive of climate change—distrust climate scientists. In response, climate scientists can undertake one of two general communication strategies for enhancing trust, each appealing to one of two broad types of cognitive processing mechanisms. In the first, the communicator displays traits like humor, attractiveness, vigorous delivery, and likeability that audiences use as heuristics in determining whom to trust. But this strategy is unlikely to be successful with the very audiences who are its main targets, since those audiences will be primed to employ a more analytic and critical approach to assessing trustworthiness. In the second communicative strategy, the communicator earns trust by undertaking burdens and commitments and making herself vulnerable in ways her audience can enforce. This vulnerability signals her trustworthiness, since the audience can reason that she would not undertake such risks unless she was confident in what she was saying. Climate scientists have a variety of ways of making themselves vulnerable, including committing themselves to engaging with doubtful and dismissive audiences, undertaking burdens of proof to argue with them, empowering audiences to assess the science themselves, admitting error, and focusing on small issues. Overall, when adopting the second strategy, climate scientists must extend trust in order to earn trust, committing themselves to an on‐going relationship within which their true trustworthiness will become apparent. WIREs Clim Change 2014, 5:151–160. doi: 10.1002/wcc.262 Conflict of interest: The authors have declared no conflicts of interest for this article. For further resources related to this article, please visit the WIREs website.

Wait Five Minutes

Wait Five Minutes
Author: Shelley Ingram
Publisher: Univ. Press of Mississippi
Total Pages: 203
Release: 2023-05-18
Genre: Social Science
ISBN: 1496844378

Download Wait Five Minutes Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Contributions by Emma Frances Bloomfield, Sheila Bock, Kristen Bradley, Hannah Chapple, James Deutsch, Máirt Hanley, Christine Hoffmann, Kate Parker Horigan, Shelley Ingram, John Laudun, Jordan Lovejoy, Lena Marander-Eklund, Jennifer Morrison, Willow G. Mullins, Anne Pryor, Todd Richardson, and Claire Schmidt The weather governs our lives. It fills gaps in conversations, determines our dress, and influences our architecture. No matter how much our lives may have moved indoors, no matter how much we may rely on technology, we still monitor the weather. Wait Five Minutes: Weatherlore in the Twenty-First Century draws from folkloric, literary, and scientific theory to offer up new ways of thinking about this most ancient of phenomena. Weatherlore is a concept that describes the folk beliefs and traditions about the weather that are passed down casually among groups of people. Weatherlore can be predictive, such as the belief that more black than brown fuzz on a woolly bear caterpillar signals a harsh winter. It can be the familiar commentary that eases daily social interactions, such as asking, “Is it hot (or cold) enough for you?” Other times, it is simply ubiquitous: “If you don’t like the weather, wait five minutes and it will change.” From detailing personal experiences at picnics and suburban lawns to critically analyzing storm stories, novels, and flood legends, contributors offer engaging multidisciplinary perspectives on weatherlore. As we move further into the twenty-first century, an increasing awareness of climate change and its impacts on daily life calls for a folkloristic reckoning with the weather and a rising need to examine vernacular understandings of weather and climate. Weatherlore helps us understand and shape global political conversations about climate change and biopolitics at the same time that it influences individual, group, and regional lives and identities. We use weather, and thus its folklore, to make meaning of ourselves, our groups, and, quite literally, our world.

Rhetorical Criticism

Rhetorical Criticism
Author: Jim A. Kuypers
Publisher: Rowman & Littlefield
Total Pages: 409
Release: 2021-07-19
Genre: Language Arts & Disciplines
ISBN: 1538138158

Download Rhetorical Criticism Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Covering a broad range of rhetorical perspectives, Rhetorical Criticism: Perspectives in Action, third edition presents a well-grounded introduction to the basics of rhetorical criticism and theory in an accessible manner for advanced undergraduate courses and introductory graduate courses. Throughout the text, sample essays written by noted experts in the field provide students with models for writing their own criticisms. In addition to covering traditional modes of rhetorical criticism, the book introduces less commonly discussed rhetorical perspectives as well as orientations toward performing criticisms including close-textual analysis, critical approaches, and analysis of visual and digital rhetoric. The third edition includes the following features: New chapters on visual rhetoric and digital rhetoric Potentials and Pitfalls sections analyzing individual perspectives Activities and discussion questions in each chapter Glossary of important terms