Anti-Competitive Behaviours and the Remedies Available for Redress

Anti-Competitive Behaviours and the Remedies Available for Redress
Author: Frederick M. Abbott
Publisher:
Total Pages: 0
Release: 2014
Genre:
ISBN:

Download Anti-Competitive Behaviours and the Remedies Available for Redress Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

In this chapter, core doctrines of competition law generally applied by national authorities are reviewed. Most competition laws examine anti-competitive behavior in relation to agreements between enterprises, on the one hand, and monopolization or abuse of dominant position, on the other. Anti-competitive activity is further viewed as either 'horizontal' or 'vertical'. Horizontal anti-competitive activity refers to conduct among independent enterprises that are suppliers of competitive (or potentially competitive) goods or services. Vertical anti-competitive activity refers to the supply chain controlled by a producer, beginning with inputs to production, into production, intermediate distribution and, ultimately, the retail sale of goods or services. Some types of agreement between enterprises are so inherently anti-competitive that proof of the existence of the agreement is sufficient to establish a violation. Such agreements are referred to either as per se anti-competitive or hard-core competition law violations. Other types of conduct that may seem anti-competitive on their face may also have a pro-competitive justification, such that competition authorities assess the balance. This balancing is often referred to as assessment under the “rule of reason”. For a competition law violation to be found, the anti-competitive aspect of the arrangement should outweigh potential pro-competitive benefits. Examples of horizontal anti-competitive behavior that are per se illegal in most jurisdictions include price-fixing among competitors, output restraints and allocation of geographic territories. Examples of vertical restraints that are per se illegal in many, but not all, jurisdictions are resale price maintenance (or fixing the minimum price at which retailers may sell) and “exclusive grantback” requirements in patent licenses. There are some significant risks of anti-competitive conduct in pharmaceuticals markets that are fairly widespread and deserve close attention from competition authorities. These include bid manipulation in procurement of health technologies, whereby a group of potential competitors may agree not to submit bids below a set price and to allocate the 'lowest set price' bid to a particular firm. Such activity may also involve inappropriate payments to government officials who might otherwise report the anti-competitive practice. Anti-competitive conduct by patent-owning enterprises may include requiring a distributor or retailer of health technologies to purchase a complete line of products as a condition of purchasing a particular product or products (i.e. a tying arrangement). Perhaps the most widely discussed form of anti-competitive conduct involving patent owners involves 'buying out' generic challenges to patents that might otherwise result in generic products entering the market at an early date. Such buyouts upset the balance legislators strive to achieve between granting patents and authorizing their challenge to foster competition. Mergers and acquisitions may adversely affect product markets by, for example, allowing combined companies to raise prices for therapies previously in competition with each other. Anti-competitive conduct affects markets for innovation, such as when a patent is illegitimately used to prevent the development of new products not within the scope of the patent, or when patent-owning companies combine to control markets. Mergers and acquisitions can affect markets for innovation by reducing potential R&D targets and opportunities. As noted earlier, competition law addresses dominant enterprises and monopolies as well as agreements between enterprises. A single enterprise (or a small group of enterprises) may alone exercise such significant power in a relevant market as to be able to raise prices above competitive market prices without concern that others will enter the market and undercut it. When an enterprise dominates a market, it does not need consensual agreements with potential competitors to control them; it may unilaterally dictate terms. One objective surrounding the control of mergers and acquisitions is to prevent an enterprise from combining with others precisely to take a dominant position in the market. This chapter concludes with a discussion of the types of remedies that are available to national authorities and private parties as redress for anti-competitive conduct. It is not uncommon for the government to enter into some form of settlement agreement with an accused enterprise pursuant to which that enterprise agrees to cease its anti-competitive activities and may also make a payment either as damages or as a penalty. Such settlements may be approved and/or supervised by courts. In some jurisdictions, particularly the United States, a good deal of competition enforcement is undertaken by private actors suing for damages. Anti-competitive conduct may also be subject to criminal penalties including substantial fines, and imprisonment for individuals. Specific types of remedies may be used to address anti-competitive conduct that is undertaken to block the introduction of generic products. This may include requiring pharmaceutical patent owners to compensate public procurement authorities, generic producers and others for damages occasioned by the unwarranted invocation of patents. Strong consideration should be given to prohibiting patent owners from “buying out” generic producers' challenges to patent validity or assertions of non-infringement. Other types of specific remedies may be considered.

International Economic Law and Governance

International Economic Law and Governance
Author: Julien Chaisse
Publisher: Oxford University Press
Total Pages: 625
Release: 2016
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 0198778252

Download International Economic Law and Governance Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Celebrating the work of Mitsuo Matsuhita, this volume focuses on dispute resolution and the law and politics of the World Trade Organization, offering a critical and scholarly analysis of the current and future state of international economic governance.

Access to Medicines and Vaccines

Access to Medicines and Vaccines
Author: Carlos M. Correa
Publisher: Springer Nature
Total Pages: 373
Release: 2022
Genre: Health economics
ISBN: 3030831140

Download Access to Medicines and Vaccines Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

"This book is an outcome of a partnership between the Max Planck Institute (MPI) for Innovation and Competition and the South Centre, which jointly organized a Global Forum on Intellectual Property, Access to Medicine and Innovation in Munich on 9-10 December 2019"--Page v

House of Commons - Business, Innovation and Skills Committee: Draft Consumer Rights Bill - HC 697-I

House of Commons - Business, Innovation and Skills Committee: Draft Consumer Rights Bill - HC 697-I
Author: Great Britain: Parliament: House of Commons: Business, Innovation and Skills Committee
Publisher: The Stationery Office
Total Pages: 102
Release: 2013-12-23
Genre: Law
ISBN: 9780215065933

Download House of Commons - Business, Innovation and Skills Committee: Draft Consumer Rights Bill - HC 697-I Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

The Government's draft Consumer Rights Bill has the potential to consolidate, simplify and modernise consumer law however issues and inconsistencies must be resolved. The current proposals would apply a statutory right that services under a contract must be provided with reasonable care and skill [a fault-based standard]. This does not provide sufficient consumer protection. The Draft Bill should require that services must achieve the stated result, or one which could be reasonably expected [an outcomes-based standard]. As the Bank of Ireland case demonstrated, the right to terminate a contract does not necessarily protect consumers from detriment. This report recommends an addition to the grey list - the indicative list of contract terms which may be regarded as unfair. The Government's proposals for enhanced consumer measures, which would require traders that have breached consumer law to compensate consumers, are welcome. However, private enforcers should also be able to use them. The collective proceedings regime has the potential to improve access to redress for victims of competition law breaches but the Government must clarify the certification requirements for such proceedings. The creation of rights and remedies for digital content is welcome, but the Government must do more to communicate how the proposals will work in practice. Under the draft Bill, the remedies available to consumers of digital content would depend on whether the content is intangible (such as a music download) or tangible (such as a CD). In appropriate circumstances, consumers should have the right to reject and obtain a refund irrespective of whether they purchase intangible or tangible digital content

Competition Law

Competition Law
Author: Richard|Bailey Whish (David)
Publisher: Oxford University Press
Total Pages: 1269
Release: 2024
Genre:
ISBN: 0198906056

Download Competition Law Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Main Developments in Trade 1995 Edition

Main Developments in Trade 1995 Edition
Author: OECD
Publisher: OECD Publishing
Total Pages: 311
Release: 1995-09-26
Genre:
ISBN: 9264162097

Download Main Developments in Trade 1995 Edition Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

This annual report, covering events in 1994, is a concise factual compendium of cross-country trade and trade-related developments.

Modern Intellectual Property Law

Modern Intellectual Property Law
Author: Jonathan Galloway
Publisher: Routledge
Total Pages: 1437
Release: 2010-07-12
Genre: Law
ISBN: 1135267693

Download Modern Intellectual Property Law Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Modern Intellectual Property Law combines coverage of each intellectual property right granted for creations of the mind into a thoughtful, unified textbook. Deconstructing the fundamental topics into short, clear sections separated by subheadings throughout, Colston and Galloway's text is the ideal student companion to this intriguing area of the law. This new edition has been completely revised to bring it up to date with the latest debate and changes to the law. All significant recent developments are covered including the continuing controversy over patents for computer-implemented inventions and biotechnological inventions, the House of Lords' developments of patent law, the ECJ jurisprudence relating to trade mark dilution and comparative advertising, as well as the database right, and international efforts to reconcile copyright with peer-to-peer file sharing. This text also discusses the ongoing effort to achieve an appropriate balance between intellectual property and competition law in order to protect market competition while retaining key incentives to drive the process of innovation. Written for students, this accessible and comprehensive textbook provides the perfect starting point for anyone studying intellectual property law in the UK.

Antitrust Basics

Antitrust Basics
Author: Thomas V. Vakerics
Publisher: Law Journal Seminars Press
Total Pages: 1200
Release: 2017-12-28
Genre: Law
ISBN: 9781588520326

Download Antitrust Basics Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

This book anticipates virtually every antitrust issue you can expect to face, including: horizontal and vertical restraints; joint ventures; private treble damage actions; price fixing; and more.

Research Handbook on Intellectual Property Exhaustion and Parallel Imports

Research Handbook on Intellectual Property Exhaustion and Parallel Imports
Author: Irene Calboli
Publisher: Edward Elgar Publishing
Total Pages: 582
Release: 2016-06-24
Genre: Law
ISBN: 1783478713

Download Research Handbook on Intellectual Property Exhaustion and Parallel Imports Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

From the Americas to the European Union, Asia-Pacific and Africa, countries around the world are facing increased pressure to clarify the application of intellectual property exhaustion. This wide-ranging Research Handbook explores the questions that pose themselves as a result. Should exhaustion apply at the national, regional, or international level? Should parallel imports be considered lawful imports? Should copyright, patent, and trademark laws follow the same regime? Should countries attempt to harmonize their approaches? To what extent should living matters and self-replicating technologies be subject to the principle of exhaustion? To what extent have the rise of digital goods and the “Internet of things” redefined the concept of exhaustion in cyberspace? The Handbook offers insights to the challenges surrounding these questions and highlights how one answer does not fit all.

Reconciling Efficiency and Equity

Reconciling Efficiency and Equity
Author: Damien Gerard
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Total Pages: 475
Release: 2019-05-09
Genre: Law
ISBN: 1108498086

Download Reconciling Efficiency and Equity Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Provides a new conceptualization of competition law as economic inequality and its interaction with efficiency become of central concern to policy and decision-makers.