Essays on Mechanism Design and the Informed Principal Problem

Essays on Mechanism Design and the Informed Principal Problem
Author: Nicholas C. Bedard
Publisher:
Total Pages: 252
Release: 2013
Genre:
ISBN:

Download Essays on Mechanism Design and the Informed Principal Problem Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Three models of a privately informed contract designer (a principal) are examined. In the first, I study how much private information the principal wants to acquire before offering a contract to an agent. Despite allowing her to acquire all information for free, I prove in a general environment that there is a nontrivial set of parameters for which it is strictly suboptimal for the principal to be completely informed, regardless of the continuation equilibrium following any information acquisition choice. This result holds even when the principal is able to employ the most general mechanisms available and, in particular, when she can choose her most favourable full-information continuation equilibria. Further, in a specialized environment I characterize the principal's optimal information choice. The second is a two-state principal-agent model with moral hazard in which the principal knows the state but the agent does not. This model is relevant to situations where an employer has private information about the productivity of a worker in a particular task while the worker has private information about the effort she exerts on the job. Much of the literature on this subject restricts the employer to offer contracts that leave her no discretion once a contract is accepted, while more general contracts may allow the employer to exercise discretion after acceptance; such contracts are called menu-contracts. I show when the employer can obtain strictly higher expected payoffs by offering menu-contracts than by offering the restricted contracts used in the literature. The final model studies the ability of a bidder in an auction to organize collusion among her rival bidders and the resulting impact of this collusion on the seller. Bidders valuations are private information. I show that in a two bidder, discrete, independent private-value auction, the seller earns less when a bidder can offer her rival a collusion proposal than in the absence of collusion. This contrasts with a cele- brated result by Che and Kim ("Robustly collusion-proof implementation". Econometrica, 74(4):1063-1107, July 2006) stating that for such auctions there is a mechanism that eliminates all the effects of collusion. Che and Kim and much of the literature assume an uninformed third-party organizes collusion.

Informed-principal Problem in Mechanisms with Limited Commitment

Informed-principal Problem in Mechanisms with Limited Commitment
Author: Suehyun Kwon
Publisher:
Total Pages:
Release: 2019
Genre:
ISBN:

Download Informed-principal Problem in Mechanisms with Limited Commitment Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

This paper studies mechanism design with limited commitment where agents have persistent correlated types over the infinite horizon. The mechanism designer now faces the informed-principal problem in addition to usual issues with i.i.d. types. With an infinite horizon and nondurable good, there is always an equilibrium where all types of mechanism designer (private information on the type distribution of agents) pool together, and the ex-ante optimality depends on the cost of agents' gaming the system. The paper also shows sufficient conditions for ob-taining the full-commitment solution with limited commitment.

Essays on Mechanism Design and Multiple Privately Informed Principals

Essays on Mechanism Design and Multiple Privately Informed Principals
Author: Nicolás Riquelme
Publisher:
Total Pages: 149
Release: 2019
Genre: Consolidation and merger of corporations
ISBN:

Download Essays on Mechanism Design and Multiple Privately Informed Principals Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

"This dissertation is a collection of three papers studying both theoretical and applied aspects of mechanism design. In Chapter 1, we study competing auctions where each seller has private information about the quality of his object and chooses the reserve price of a second-price auction. Buyers observe the reserve prices and decide which auction to participate in. For a class of primitives, we show that a perfect Bayesian equilibrium exists for any finite market. In any such PBE, higher quality is signaled through higher reserve price at the expense of trade opportunities. But there might be bunching regions causing inefficiencies. In fact, in the large-market limit characterized by a directed search model, the interaction of adverse selection and search frictions entail distortion at the bottom: when either the buyer-seller ratio is sufficiently large or a regularity condition is met, there is no separating PBE in which the lowest-quality seller sets reserve price equal to his opportunity cost. This finding carries over to large finite markets and is consistent with observed behavior in auctions for used cars in UK (Choi, Nesheim and Rasul, 2016). In Chapter 2, we study games where a group of privately informed principals design mechanisms to a common agent. The agent has private information (exogenous) and, after observing principals' mechanisms, may have information (endogenous) about feasible allocations and private information from each principal. Thus, each principal may be interested in designing a mechanism to screen all this information, for which a potentially complicated message space to convey this information might be needed. In this project, we provide sufficient conditions on the agent's payoff such that any equilibrium in this setup has an output-equivalent equilibrium using only mechanisms with simple message spaces (direct mechanisms). Depending on the conditions, we propose two different notions of direct mechanisms and discuss their applicability with some examples. In Chapter 3, we study the design of horizontal merger regulation in a Cournot competition setting, where firms are privately informed about production technology. More specifically, a consumer-surplus-maximizer regulator designs a mechanism which determines whether the merger is blocked or accepted, and sets structural remedies (divestitures). This problem does not have the usual quasi-linear structure commonly assumed in the mechanism design literature. We first characterize incentive-compatible mechanisms and then find the optimal one. The complete information case is also presented as a benchmark. Asymmetric information induces important distortions in regulatory decisions. First, every rejected merge would improve consumer surplus. Second, every merge that decreases consumer surplus would be approved. Lastly, every merge rightly approved would be asked fewer divestitures than the optimal one (under-fixing effect). These results seem consistent with recent empirical evidence on the ineffectiveness of the merger regulation"--Pages vii-viii.

Mechanism Design

Mechanism Design
Author: Rakesh V. Vohra
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Total Pages: 185
Release: 2011-05-09
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 1139499173

Download Mechanism Design Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Mechanism design is an analytical framework for thinking clearly and carefully about what exactly a given institution can achieve when the information necessary to make decisions is dispersed and privately held. This analysis provides an account of the underlying mathematics of mechanism design based on linear programming. Three advantages characterize the approach. The first is simplicity: arguments based on linear programming are both elementary and transparent. The second is unity: the machinery of linear programming provides a way to unify results from disparate areas of mechanism design. The third is reach: the technique offers the ability to solve problems that appear to be beyond solutions offered by traditional methods. No claim is made that the approach advocated should supplant traditional mathematical machinery. Rather, the approach represents an addition to the tools of the economic theorist who proposes to understand economic phenomena through the lens of mechanism design.

Mechanism Design

Mechanism Design
Author: Arthur G. Erdman
Publisher:
Total Pages: 664
Release: 1990
Genre: Technology & Engineering
ISBN:

Download Mechanism Design Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

Social Organization and Mechanism Design

Social Organization and Mechanism Design
Author: Claude d' Aspremont
Publisher: De Boeck Supérieur
Total Pages: 348
Release: 1999
Genre: Social Science
ISBN: 9782804129941

Download Social Organization and Mechanism Design Book in PDF, Epub and Kindle

By presenting a collection of contributions by leading experts, this book illustrates the variety of issues that the discipline of "mechanism design", as a branch of game theory, is capable of dealing with : voting rules, trial procedures, public good production, cost-sharing, monopolistic regulation, bequest function, etc. However, the book illustrates also the fundamental unity of the basic questions : information gathering, communication, individual as well as coalitional strategic and dynamic behavior.